The Human Consciousness Now...Our World in the Midst of Becoming...to What? Observe, contemplate Now.
DHAKA, Bangladesh, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - The world’s highest court has delivered a historic legal and moral victory. It does not get any more definitive than this. On 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State. It is the first time the court has held a state responsible for committing genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. By a 9–6 majority, the judges also found that Myanmar failed to prevent and punish genocide. The ICJ has spoken for the Rohingya. The ruling is final, and there is nowhere left to appeal. However, turning this verdict into a safe journey home will take political muscle that the court itself does not have. The international community must act now.

Dr Mohammad Zaman
The case was brought in November 2019 by The Gambia, a small West African state with no direct connection to the crimes, backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The court examined the military’s 2017 “clearance operations” in detail: an estimated 10,000 Rohingya killed, and nearly 400 villages, about 40 per cent of those in three northern townships, partly or wholly destroyed before being bulldozed and built over. It concluded that Myanmar’s security forces intentionally killed members of the group, caused them serious bodily and mental harm, and imposed measures intended to prevent births.
Reading the judgment, ICJ President Yuji Iwasawa said: “The evidence of brutal acts of sexual violence and the targeting of children for violence in Rohingya communities also supports an inference that there was a desire to destroy the foundations of the group. The systematic nature of these actions further indicates a reasonable inference that Myanmar acted with genocidal intent.”
A legal and moral victory
The legal weight of this ruling is hard to overstate. In the 2007 Bosnia case, the court found that Serbia had failed to prevent the Srebrenica genocide but stopped short of holding it responsible for committing genocide. This time there is no such hedge. The court also made clear that genocidal intent can coexist with other aims, including military ones. That undercuts Myanmar’s long-standing claim that it was simply fighting an insurgency.
The moral victory matters just as much. For decades, the Rohingya have been denied citizenship, confined to camps and dismissed by Myanmar’s generals. Now the world’s highest court has put their suffering on the authoritative record. UN Secretary-General António Guterres called the ruling a “powerful recognition of the Rohingya victims of genocide”. That recognition cannot be undone, and it is a form of justice in its own right.
What the court ordered, and what it cannot do
The court’s directives are binding. Myanmar must stop any ongoing violations and pass legislation giving full effect to the Convention. It must investigate, prosecute and punish those responsible, and give guarantees that the atrocities will not happen again. It must also provide restitution, including the “safe, voluntary and dignified return” of displaced Rohingya to their homes and the reunification of families, and compensate the victims. Myanmar has two years to report on what it has done.
In practical terms, little is likely to change in the short run. The ICJ has no police force. Nor does it try individuals: it rules on disputes between states. The fate of Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, who oversaw the 2017 campaign and now heads the state, lies with the International Criminal Court. The ICC prosecutor’s pending warrant application against him now carries greater weight.
Enforcement and the politics of the veto
If Myanmar ignores the judgment, just as The Gambia says it failed to comply with the court’s 2020 provisional measures, The Gambia can take the matter to the UN Security Council under Article 94 of the UN Charter. This is where justice meets geopolitics. Any one of the five permanent members can veto action, and history offers little comfort. When the court ruled against the United States in the Nicaragua case in 1986, Washington vetoed the resolutions calling for compliance. In 2007, China and Russia vetoed a draft resolution on Myanmar’s human rights record.
China holds the key
No country matters more here than China. Beijing is Myanmar’s most important patron. It has shielded Naypyidaw at the UN, invested heavily in Rakhine and has acted as a broker between the junta and ethnic armed groups. Its priority is stability along its economic corridor to the Bay of Bengal, not accountability.
The situation on the ground complicates matters further. The junta has lost much of Rakhine State to the Arakan Army, and Myanmar has been in turmoil for years. When the ICJ orders a safe return to the Rohingya’s “place of residence”, Naypyidaw can simply say it no longer controls the territory. Any credible repatriation will therefore have to be negotiated with both the junta and the Arakan Army, most likely with Beijing as guarantor. China wants Rakhine stable and its investments secure. If Dhaka and its partners can show that an orderly, rights-based return serves that goal, China’s interests may line up with the court’s orders.
What Bangladesh should do now
Bangladesh has carried the heaviest burden of a crisis it did not create. About 1.4 million Rohingya now live in the camps around Cox’s Bazar. Since 2017, repatriation talks have produced little. The verdict gives Dhaka a kind of leverage it has never had before. It should use the verdict to work with allies to find out a workable solution.
First, make the judgment the baseline. Every repatriation deal should meet the court’s standard: a safe, voluntary and dignified return to the Rohingya’s original homes, not to transit camps, with a clear path to citizenship.
Second, talk to whoever controls the ground. Dhaka should engage the Arakan Army pragmatically, alongside Naypyidaw, so that any agreement can be carried out in Rakhine.
Third, work with China, not around it. Bangladesh should press Beijing to guarantee a deal and present a stable, rights-based return as good for China’s investments.
Fourth, build a coalition for compliance. Bangladesh should work with The Gambia, the OIC, the 11 states that intervened in the case, ASEAN and Japan to keep Myanmar’s compliance before the UN General Assembly and Security Council, and to hold Myanmar to its two-year reporting deadline.
Finally, keep the Rohingya at the centre. Refugees must have a voice in any negotiation. Reparations must reach those living in Bangladesh, and humanitarian funding, education and livelihoods in the camps must be protected while talks continue.
From verdict to homecoming
The ICJ has done its part. It has named the crime, identified the state responsible and set out what justice requires. The verdict will not, by itself, send a single family home. But it changes the terms of every conversation about the Rohingya from this day on. Whether it becomes a turning point or a footnote now depends on what allies and states do next, starting with Bangladesh.
Dr. Mohammad Zaman has written extensively on the Rohingya crisis since 2017. His recent edited (co-editors Robert Anderson and Kawser Ahmed) book is titled Rohingya Stories: History and Geopolitics in a Multipolar World (Springer 2025).
IPS UN Bureau

LAGOS, Nigeria, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - In too many communities across our continent, a baby born with a cleft lip or palate is met with fear instead of a plan. Some families are told the child is cursed. Some mothers are even forced out of their homes. Yet a cleft is one of the most common and treatable conditions in medicine. A safe operation, done early, lets a child eat, speak and grow up with a bright future.
So when that child goes untreated, the problem is not biology. It is a sign that something is missing: the surgeon, the anesthetist, the nurse, the working operating room, the reliable electricity, the road to the right hospital. In this way, cleft is a bellwether for the strength of health systems overall.
Across sub-Saharan Africa, 93% of people cannot get safe, affordable surgery and anaesthesia when they need it, compared with under 4% in wealthier regions. In Ethiopia alone, roughly five million needed operations go undone each year.
From November 19 to 21, health leaders, surgeons, researchers and partners from across Africa will meet in Addis Ababa for the fourth Pan-African Surgical Healthcare Forum (PASHeF). Its goal is ambitious and overdue: a continental action framework for surgical care.

A doctor measures the nutritional development of a cleft patient at a hospital in Tanzania. Credit: Smile Train
Surgery is health care, not a luxury
For decades, surgery was treated as something that could wait until vaccines, bed nets, and clinics were in place. As a result of that longstanding underinvestment, an estimated 93 million Africans need surgical care every year, yet only about 5% receive it.
The World Health Assembly has recognized emergency and essential surgery and anaesthesia as a core part of universal health coverage. Invest in surgical capability, and you strengthen the whole hospital’s ability to deliver across a wide range of needs: emergency care, safe childbirth, trauma, cancer.
Ethiopia took that commitment seriously. In 2016, it became one of the first countries to write a national surgical plan, Saving Lives Through Safe Surgery (SaLTS).
What we have learned
Hundreds of new operating room blocks are being built at health centres, and surgical indicators are now tracked in the national health information system.
The challenges were familiar: leadership changes, too little reliable data, and no dedicated budget to reach the whole country. A study of the plan’s rollout found that government ownership was the most important ingredient for success.
Experience from outside government points the same way. Over 25 years, Smile Train’s approach has been to support local teams working inside national systems rather than fly in visiting surgeons. Those teams have now performed nearly 250,000 free cleft surgeries across Africa, more than 46,000 of them in Ethiopia since 2007. Three lessons stand out.
Build with government, not beside it. In Kumasi, Ghana, the Ministry of Health, Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital and the Ghana Cleft Foundation co-created the National Cleft Care Center. Government clinicians staff it, and cleft surgery there has gone from one day a week to every day.
Train together. When Africa’s surgical colleges agreed on a single cleft surgery curriculum, it spread across the continent in English, French and Portuguese.
Fix the basics. A well-equipped theatre is useless in a blackout, yet families are still asked to bring diesel for the generator. Solar systems installed with Kids Operating Room now power more than 85 children’s operating theatres in 28 countries, three of which are public hospitals in Ethiopia.
Together they show what works: government ownership, a local workforce, data that is tracked, and infrastructure that actually runs.
What the framework must do
The Addis Ababa forum should commit African governments to four key things:
• Put surgery in the budget. Plans without money stall. Finance ministries belong at the table from day one, and domestic funding should anchor what partners add.• Train and keep the workforce. Shared regional curricula, scholarships, and alumni networks can prepare young specialists to replace an aging generation of surgeons.
• Count what matters. Every country should track surgical access and outcomes in its national health data, as Ethiopia now does with its registry.
• Start with families. Ending the stigma around conditions like cleft takes midwives, community health workers, religious leaders and traditional rulers, not just doctors.
A year ago, the African Union and Africa CDC unveiled the Health Security and Sovereignty Agenda, a blueprint for African countries to build stronger health institutions, finance health from their own resources and grow local capacity. Surgery is where that ambition is tested: a country that can staff, equip, power and pay for its own operating theatres can meet its people’s needs on its own terms.
These steps can have a meaningful impact now and for future generations. As long as children are born, some will be born with a cleft. A poor child in a rural district deserves the same chance of a safe operation as an affluent child in a capital city. This week in Addis Ababa, Africa’s leaders can commit to making that happen.
Nkeiruka Obi is Vice President and Regional Director, Africa, Smile Train
IPS UN Bureau

ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - Civil society organisations and delegates from climate-vulnerable countries have sharply criticised the latest draft of the Presidency-led cover decision at the UN climate summit. They accuse negotiators of removing commitments on fossil fuels and failing to provide concrete climate finance, as the talks enter their final hours.
Released by the COP31 Presidency on November 19, the second draft of the cover text removes all direct references to fossil fuels and drops proposed roadmaps for moving away from them. Both had appeared in an earlier version released on November 16.
Instead, the new draft proposes a target to increase electricity’s share of final energy consumption to 35 percent by 2035. It also launches the Antalya Compact for Energy Efficient Buildings and retains unresolved, bracketed language supporting carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS) and carbon dioxide removal (CDR).
Although the draft reaffirms the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C temperature goal and sets up new dialogues on oceans and mountains, climate advocates say the removal of key commitments marks a major step backwards on cutting emissions and ensuring fairness for countries most affected by climate change.
Accusations Over Fossil Fuel Omissions
Speaking at a press conference after the draft was released, Andreas Sieber, Head of Political Strategy at 350.org, strongly criticised the removal of fossil fuel language and singled out Chris Bowen, COP31 President of Negotiations and Australia’s Climate Change and Energy Minister.
“The COP President, Bowen, seems to be some kind of spineless fossil fuel bro, after what we’ve seen in the latest cover decision draft,” Sieber said, pointing to the economic ties between the summit’s co-hosts.
“He cut out, and it seems to be quite conveniently, any reference to fossil fuels. We know that Australia is one of the top fossil fuel exporters in the world. They’re currently number two in coal exports, about to become number one. If there’s one thing that connects these two presidencies… it’s the coal trade between Australia and Turkey.”
Sieber said the coal traded between the two countries since the Paris Agreement represents four times Ethiopia’s annual carbon dioxide emissions. Ethiopia is due to host COP32.
He also called for the removal of language promoting carbon capture technologies, specifically demanding that paragraph 36(h) be “killed.” If countries cannot agree on fossil fuel phase-out roadmaps through the formal negotiations, he urged the presidency to continue pushing for them outside the negotiating rooms.
Stalled Negotiations and Distractions
Other climate advocates warned that the Presidency’s cover text is diverting attention from the formal negotiations, particularly discussions on how to protect workers and communities as countries move away from fossil fuels.
Natasha Greene, an advisor and specialist in international climate diplomacy and energy transition at E3G Australia, pointed to the absence of a mechanism to coordinate a fair transition away from fossil fuels.
“There will be a fight also to advance the just transition mechanism. It hasn’t been mentioned in the cover decision text, but it was a priority for those who wanted to say, yes, we need to look to ban fossil fuels,” Greene said.
She added that progress on the mechanism was “being stalled by negotiating tactics from the European Union, from Australia, and from other countries that don’t want to codify obligations around just transition and internationalise them.”
Carla Daniela Maass Wolfenson of Ecuador’s Sacred Head Waters Alliance also questioned the process behind the cover decision.
“We came here not to discuss this text,” she said, arguing that the cover decision had effectively created a parallel negotiating process. In her view, this was taking attention away from the formal discussions on emissions cuts, just transition and climate finance.
Vulnerable Nations Await Concrete Finance
On adaptation, the November 19 draft launches the Antalya-to-Addis Ababa Roadmap for Adaptation and Resilience Finance. However, it does not set a specific funding target or baseline year for tripling adaptation finance.
For delegates from countries facing conflict and severe climate impacts, the absence of clear financial commitments has serious consequences for people already struggling to cope with multiple crises.
Samer Kalbouneh, head of the Palestinian delegation, stressed the urgent need for financial and technological support to rebuild Gaza’s shattered infrastructure.
“Eighty percent of our productive land is now unproductive because of the war. We are completely dependent for energy on Israel and our water supply systems are broken,” Kalbouneh told IPS.
“What we aim for at this moment is to stress the importance of letting the environmental finance continue, from developed countries to fragile and more affected countries like Palestine, and especially in Gaza,” he added.
Fadumo Abdilahi, gender focal point for the Somali delegation, described how women in her country face overlapping crises, including drought, flooding and violence by the extremist group Al-Shabaab. At the same time, many women continue to support their families and local economies through small businesses and subsistence farming.
“Year after year, we come to the COP, hoping that things will change, that vulnerable communities like us will get finance that will help women become more climate resilient,” Abdilahi told IPS.
Official Defence and Final Push
At a press conference shortly after the draft was released, COP31 officials leading the negotiations defended the process, maintaining that the complex talks were still focused on delivering action.
Minister Chris Bowen described the summit as the “COP of implementation and acceleration”. He emphasised the need for concrete plans to drive an “irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions” and keep the 1.5°C goal within reach.
UNFCCC Executive Secretary Simon Stiell acknowledged that addressing the many issues being negotiated across different rooms was “very complex.” However, he stressed that “these are crucial days ahead for climate cooperation. And we have no time to lose.”
Despite the strong criticism of the latest draft, some observers believe there is still time to secure a stronger outcome before the negotiations end.
Greene of E3G said the language on moving away from fossil fuels could still make it back into the final text in the remaining hours.
“They have the diplomatic skill to pull this through,” she said.
IPS UN Bureau Report

COX’S BAZAR, Bangladesh & THE HAGUE, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - Cheers and celebrations erupted in mass refugee camps across the border from Myanmar on Thursday as a landmark world court ruling found the military regime had committed genocide against its Rohingya minority.
Crowds gathered around screens set up in Jamtoli, one of a complex of camps of bamboo and tarpaulin shelters for over one million refugees in Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh, to listen to the live reading of the verdict of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague.
After nearly three hours of reading the court’s final statement, ICJ president Judge Yuji Iwasawa of Japan finally pronounced the first-ever ruling by an international court convicting a state of genocide.
By nine votes to six, he said, the judges of the 80-year-old court established by the UN Charter found that Myanmar had “committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine state”.
Crowds cheered and applauded across Cox’s Bazar as interpreters used loudhailers to convey the message they had waited years for.
“It’s a historic moment for the Rohingya and for the people of Myanmar, for all people who are suffering under different crises around the world. Today the ICJ also recognised the truth and reality, and the world wins today,” declared Mohammed Tofile, a 30-year-old activist.
“It is proof that the world stands against impunity, dictatorship, and brutality. It’s a starting point for accountability,” he told IPS, thanking Gambia for bringing the case to the ICJ, supporters of the Rohingya across the world, and Bangladesh for hosting over one million refugees.
The court’s investigations, hearings and deliberations had taken seven years to complete, focusing mostly on the events of 2017 when the Myanmar military launched what it called “clearance operations” in Rakhine state following attacks by Rohingya militants on police units.
The ICJ’s genocide verdict is sure to trigger widespread debate as the nine judges upholding the conviction found there was sufficient circumstantial evidence to infer genocidal “intent”, an essential element in a decision under the 1948 Genocide Convention.
Some defenders of Israel, and particularly members of the US administration, had warned the 15 ICJ judges not to “lower the bar” in seeking a genocide conviction, fearing a precedent would be set. Israel is facing a case before the ICJ, brought by South Africa, over Gaza.
In reaching 13 separate rulings, the ICJ also found that Myanmar had violated its obligations to prevent genocide committed by individuals alongside its security forces, that it had covered up evidence of crimes of genocide, and that it had failed to enact legislation to prevent genocide, nor had it punished perpetrators.
Specifically, the court found that the numbers of civilians among the more than 10,000 people killed far outweighed combatants and that civilians were killed as they fled to Bangladesh among a total of 700,000 crossing the border.
Sexual violence committed by armed forces and others was “pervasive and systematic”, gang rapes of women were commonplace, and credible estimates indicated that over 730 children under the age of five had been killed. Boys and men were executed. Nearly 400 villages in northern Rakhine were partially or totally destroyed.
During the 2017 “clearance operations”, hate speech against the Rohingya by Min Aung Hlaing – the then military commander who elevated himself to the presidency this year – was systematically disseminated, while the military whipped up anti-Rohingya diatribes through sympathisers on Facebook.
The court set the violence in the context of decades of discrimination and stigmatisation against the mostly Moslem community in predominantly Buddhist Myanmar, with the intent of reducing their numbers. A 1982 law stripped most Rohingya of their citizenship; restrictions in the main township were placed on marriage and childbirth; access to higher education and freedom of movement were denied or curbed.
In another historic first – one that also exposes the court’s lack of powers of enforcement – the ICJ ordered Myanmar to make reparations by facilitating the safe and voluntary return of refugees to their homes, or failing that, compensation. Myanmar was given two years to report back with the ICJ to determine modalities and amounts.
But the reality is that the Myanmar regime has lost control over most of Rakhine to ethnic Arakan insurgents in the civil war that erupted after Min Aung Hlaing ousted Aung San Suu Kyi’s elected government in 2021. Now installed as president, he travels freely these days among neighbouring countries and between his main allies, China and Russia. The US is also engaging with his regime.
The ICJ’s mandate allows it to adjudicate only cases between states, not prosecute individuals, and must rely on the UN Security Council and political pressure to back up its rulings. The UK expressed its support on Thursday and expelled Myanmar’s defence attaché.
The Trump administration had already expressed its displeasure with the ICJ judges before they issued their rulings. The powerful juxtaposition of President Trump joining on Thursday with Russia’s Vladimir Putin in the summit hosted by President Xi Jinping of China did not go unnoticed, with the reform of the UN on the agenda.
Despite all this, the Rohingya know this is their moment of vindication.
“Today the world’s highest court has confirmed what the Rohingya people have said for years: what happened to us was genocide,” said Mohammed Amin, head of the Rohingya Centre of the United Kingdom. He attended the hearing in The Hague with his mother, who carried him out of Rakhine aged three.
“To hear it is very emotional. We were denied for so long, and now the law has recognised the truth, and no one can deny it any more. This judgment belongs to the families in the camps, to those still living in Arakan, and to those we lost,” he told IPS.
Sabekun Naher, founder of Arakan Network for Women’s Rights, was 11 years old when she fled the carnage in Myanmar with her family, her grandfather dying along the way. She told IPS in Cox’s Bazar that she felt goosebumps and cried while listening to the ICJ ruling.
“As a Rohingya woman, I feel incredibly happy. I am sure many other Rohingya women feel the same way, perhaps even more deeply,” she said.
She earnestly thanked The Gambia for its support and the ICJ judges. “Until today, there seemed to be confusion and disagreement over whether the atrocities committed against us constituted genocide and whether we, as Rohingya, truly belong to Myanmar. Today, I feel that this confusion has been clarified and addressed,” she said.
IPS UN Bureau Report

NAIROBI, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - Last week, on 11 November, Kenya discharged its last Ebola patient, just 37 days after the country recorded the first-ever case of the virus in its territory. If no new cases emerge over the next six weeks, Kenya will be officially declared Ebola free on 23 December. So far, zero community transmission has been recorded in the country.
That’s an outcome that Kenya can be proud of, and it’s not just a case of good luck. In June – shortly after the Ebola outbreak had been declared in Uganda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, but months before Kenya saw its first case – Kenya’s National Public Health Institute (KNPHI) invited a Ugandan epidemiologist to teach some 200 Kenyan health workers the importance of investigating every health alert and looking into every unexplained death.
Using simple digital tools to both support and elevate local expertise is a quick, cost effective way to ensure that communities – and nations – stand robust in the face of outbreaks
And when Kenya’s first case was declared on October 6, KNPHI sprang into action, running twice-weekly virtual training sessions for frontline health workers and surveillance officers across the country. The Ugandan experiences, particularly on contact tracing, became essential here, helping Kenyan public health officials break the chain of transmission.
That kind of response – both nimble and far-reaching – is precisely what’s needed to contain an outbreak of a disease like Ebola. KNPHI was able to move fast and reach so many people thanks to virtual networks that were set up before the outbreak reached Kenya. Africa needs more investment in these kinds of networks, which my organization, Project ECHO, supports – not just in the middle of a crisis, but before the next emergency hits.
One reason that virtual networks are so powerful is that they elevate the voices of community members, which are our strongest shields against future outbreaks. Local health workers, officials, faith leaders, civil society groups, and trusted volunteers are often able to spot unusual health events before formal systems do.
Engaging with community leaders also allows us to combine global expertise with essential local context. As we’ve seen with Ebola, a failure to respect local traditions regarding burial practices, for example, has proven to be a serious challenge in containing the disease’s spread.
Embedding medical best practice with established and respected members of the local community – who understand the cultural context, and can work through it – can help us guard against such challenges.
Investing in virtual networks permanently strengthens local health capacity, which is ultimately our strongest protection against future outbreaks. Recent funding cuts to the WHO and other global health programs have undercut health staffing in many communities, making such networks more essential than ever.
Networks that include community health workers can also be used to spread knowledge and information to communities between outbreaks – which is just as essential as emergency response.
In Senegal, for example, the Institut Pasteur runs virtual training sessions on hemorrhagic and viral diseases that are reaching healthcare workers in communities across francophone West Africa and beyond.
And in Zambia, where the government has embraced virtual learning networks for more than a decade, regional and local information hubs are actively connecting frontline health workers with national and international expertise in real time, accelerating the sharing of evolving guidance, supporting mentorship, and creating peer networks that reduce professional isolation.
Even in conflict zones these digital networks have proved remarkably resilient. Since 2023, Sudan has been torn apart by civil war, genocide and gender-based violence. But an international digital network, built in close collaboration with local partners, has enabled global experts to train Sudanese health workers on how to treat victims of rape and other violence.
Some of the sessions have been facilitated through Telegram to accommodate the limited Internet bandwidth. Sometimes, the sessions take place late at night, when the connection is stronger.
The cases of Senegal, Zambia and Sudan show what’s possible when technology is used to serve local leadership. As we respond to the ongoing Ebola outbreak – and as we prepare for future crises – we must apply these lessons at scale.
We will always need high-level expertise and cutting-edge medicine. But we cannot let our investments in those areas distract us from investing in the networks that reach the communities on the frontlines, and that allow for cultural considerations to be taken into account. Using simple digital tools to both support and elevate local expertise is a quick, cost effective way to ensure that communities – and nations – stand robust in the face of outbreaks.
Existing virtual networks gave KNPHI the digital infrastructure it needed to move quickly in response to Kenya’s first Ebola case, broadcasting essential information to frontline health workers and surveillance officers across the country in a matter of days. Africa needs more of these virtual networks to reach communities across the continent – to protect the communities themselves, and to protect us all.
Dr. Caroline Kisia is Africa Director of Project ECHO.
ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - “This is about the survival of people, and we should not sugarcoat anything here at COP31. If you are trying to sugarcoat things, you shouldn’t be coming. We should be frustrated all the time because we are dealing with the very lives of our people.”
Tuvalu’s Minister for Climate Change and Pacific Political Champion of Mitigation, Dr Maina Vakafua Talia, does not believe there is room for complacency in the climate negotiations.
For him, the urgency is measured by whether his people will still have a country they can call home.
Talia has been part of the climate negotiations since COP18 in Doha, Qatar. Fourteen years later, he remains in the same fight, carrying a responsibility he says extends far beyond his position in government.
“I continue to be part of this because it’s important for the survival of our people,” he says.
“I think the survival element is what keeps us all going, not just for me, but for all the Pacific negotiators, our Pacific ministers, and those who have taken the fort way before us.”
At the centre of that commitment is a simple message he says the world must understand: Tuvaluans do not want to leave their islands.
“If you ask some of our elders, the answer is very straightforward. We don’t want to leave. This is our God-given land.”
For Talia, the prospect of displacement cannot be reduced to a conversation about relocation, migration or adapting to a changing environment.
It is a question of what happens to people when they lose the land that holds their history, language, culture and identity.
“Losing an island is literally losing your identity, losing your culture, losing your language, and we’re nothing. We don’t want to end up as second-class citizens in another country. We don’t want to pack and leave.”
He speaks of his mother, who has passed away, and the question he would face if he were forced to leave Tuvalu.
“My mum passed, and if I am asked to move, the biggest question for me is, ‘How are we going to look after those who are resting in the land?'”
He explains that in Pacific belief, those who have gone before are not simply gone.
“Those who went before us, they are not dead; they are just resting.”
It is this connection between land, ancestry and belonging that gives the negotiations a deeply personal meaning for him.
“The issue is not simply whether Tuvalu can adapt to rising seas. It is whether future generations will have the same relationship with their homeland that generations before them knew.”
Talia has four children and is soon to become a grandfather. He says the responsibility to keep fighting is also about the future they deserve.
“I can be in government today, and I can be outside government tomorrow, but we should never lose sight of this. We should continue to fight.”
He describes the climate crisis as an issue of justice, security and sovereignty, particularly for countries whose contribution to global emissions is negligible.
“Our contribution is almost next to nothing. It’s 0.0001. Why do our children have to suffer at the expense of other people? That’s injustice.”
It is also why he rejects the suggestion that Pacific ministers and negotiators should temper their frustration during international climate meetings.
Asked why he and other Pacific representatives appear angry during negotiations, his response is unequivocal.
“We are dealing with the very survival of our people that cannot come to COPs to speak for themselves, to tell their stories. We are here on behalf of 10,000 people. We are here on behalf of millions of people who cannot attend the COP meeting.”
For Talia, the responsibility of representing those communities demands honesty about what is happening and what is not being delivered.
“You cannot live a lie,” he said.
“You cannot romanticise climate change and tell people that you give me the money, and then we will do this. We will tick the box. No, you are playing around with the livelihoods of people.”
He says progress remains too slow, despite years of negotiations and commitments.
“We should have that feeling of being frustrated, being angry, that little changes are coming slowly, too slow.”
He is equally critical of the contradiction between financial commitments to vulnerable Pacific countries and continued investment in fossil fuels by major economies.
“We want some moral guidance, moral clarity, and moral leadership. We cannot continue to say that we will provide financial support to the Pacific, and then on the other hand, we will continue to entertain opening new coal mines or extending the life of other coal mines.”
His analogy is direct: “We cannot continue to mop the floor while not closing the tap.”
For Talia, the transition away from fossil fuels must be accompanied by political decisions that match the urgency of the climate crisis.
That is why Tuvalu is preparing to host the second international meeting on transitioning away from fossil fuels, following the process initiated in Santa Marta, Colombia, co-chaired by Colombia and the Netherlands.
He sees the meeting as an opportunity for the Pacific to take a leading role in shaping the global transition.
“Tuvalu and the Pacific never waited or stood on the sideline – we always lead and so the leadership from the Pacific is important.”
At COP31, that leadership is also reflected in the positions he is pushing through the negotiations as the Pacific’s Political Champion of Mitigation.
The region continues to fight to keep the 1.5°C temperature limit within reach, secure the continuation of the mitigation work programme and accelerate the implementation of decisions already agreed at previous COPs.
Talia says there has been strong resistance to continuing the mitigation work programme, but Pacific negotiators are working to keep it on the table.
“We want to fast-track, and we want to implement some of the decisions that have been made in previous COPs.”
He argues that keeping 1.5°C alive cannot be separated from climate finance, adaptation and implementation on the ground.
For Tuvalu, the stakes are immediate. The country has experienced dry spells in recent months, while the prospect of changing weather patterns and El Niño adds further pressure on communities already exposed to climate impacts.
“We don’t need to convince the world that they need to put money into the Pacific Resilience Facility (PRF), we don’t need to convince the world that they need to respond because it is already there,” Talia said. “They need to put money into the Loss and Damage Fund.”
His message is that the Pacific is not asking the world to imagine what climate change might mean. Its people are already living with the consequences.
After 14 years in the negotiations, Talia knows the process can be exhausting. He describes COP as psychologically damaging for those who repeatedly have to return to the negotiating rooms and argue for action on issues that determine whether their communities can remain where they are.
“We should not treat COP as a place where we meet friends or as a place where we see one another. It’s a frustrating process, and we should take advantage of the opportunity of coming and tell the world that we are not happy with how things are progressing.”
There is little separation between the political responsibility he carries and the personal future he is trying to protect.
His children, his future grandchild, the elders who want to remain on their land and the generations resting beneath it are all part of the same argument he takes into the negotiating rooms.
For Talia, the measure of success is not simply what governments agree to at the end of COP31. It is whether those decisions give Tuvaluans a genuine chance to remain on their islands, preserve their identity and determine their own future.
“We are not here to play; we are not here on a holiday trip, but we are here because of the survival of our people.”
IPS UN Bureau Report

ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - The publication timetable for several climate reports has become one of the most contentious issues at this year’s United Nations climate conference, as several fossil-fuel-dependent countries want to delay the next round of scientific assessments.
The scientific reports, released every five to seven years by the UN-backed Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), help governments plan their climate policies.
Limited Resources for Africa’s Scientists
Several African countries, including Kenya, are also among those at COP31 pushing for a delay to the report. But for them, this is not about the fact that they heavily rely on fossil fuels but about a lack of capacity building and limited resources. Kenya generates 90% of its electricity from renewables, according to the International Energy Agency.
Patricia Achieng’ Nying’uro, Kenya’s (IPCC) Focal Point, said that Kenya’s position on the Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) timeline comes down to capacity, not politics.
“We are in favour of a schedule that gives our technical reviewers, negotiators, and authors enough time and support to engage properly with the process,” she told reporters at the Conference of the Parties, or COP31, in Antakya, Turkey.
“We have a history of under-representation across the cycles, and we have an opportunity with AR7 to remedy this to some extent.”
The IPCC Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) cycle began in July 2023. Member governments have not agreed on a final delivery date.
Countries like China, Saudi Arabia, India and Russia are pushing to delay the report from 2028 to 2029, saying they want wider participation from developing nations.
Countries like Chad and some island nations want to align AR7 publication timelines and budget lines with the 2028 Global Stocktake.https://www.ipcc.ch/meeting-doc/ipcc-65/
At the IPCC’s 65th plenary session in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in October, Chair Jim Skea suspended the session after delegates did not agree on the dates.
Nying’uro said several of the authors already involved in AR7 have raised concerns about time and workload constraints.
“As an example, many scientists from developing countries, including the focal point teams, are not given dedicated time off their regular jobs for IPCC work, so they are juggling it alongside everything else they do,” she said.
Nying’uro said a compressed timeline only deepens that strain and risks the region being under-represented in the final product.
“Ultimately, what we care about most is that the IPCC’s assessment stays robust and genuinely representative of the regions it covers, and we think that depends as much on giving people the capacity to do the work well as it does on the calendar itself,” she said.
Countries Making Profit From Fossil Fuels Protect Own Interests
Critics say that China, Russia, Saudi Arabia and India, countries that make billions of dollars from fossil fuels, are protecting their own interests under the guise of inclusivity of developing nations.
Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland and founding member of The Elders, an independent group of global leaders, said that developed nations can address the lack of resources and capacity building for scientists from developing countries without delaying the report.
“There are legitimate concerns among African countries about capacity building, and they should be addressed. But that is a separate, important issue on its own. It is not a reason to hold up, try to undermine the IPCC itself,” she said.
She said it is important for the Seventh Assessment Report to be published in time for the next Global Stocktake.
“We know that science is under attack in different parts of the world, and there is a lot of disinformation and misinformation. Actually, those timelines are the timelines that the scientists have agreed on. And they should proceed,” Tubiana said.
She said that countries like Saudi Arabia are blocking the release of the report, but vulnerable countries like Nepal and island nations want its release so they can make informed decisions.
“Because it is vital for them to prepare themselves. And also, the least developed countries and developing countries can benefit much from the assessment reports,” Tubiana said.
“The most vulnerable of the developing countries badly want this report because they do not have the capacity to have separate reports. They rely on the report.”
The AR7 will provide coverage for loss and damage for the first time.
Laurence Tubiana, chief executive officer of the European Climate Foundation, said that the delay is not about scientific position but political.
“Equity is important. The contribution of scientists from the Global South, wherever they are, is very central. The real motive behind this attack is that it is a political enterprise. It is not scientific positioning,” she said.
Tubiana said that there is a need to mobilise resources to capacitate the least developed and developing countries.
“This is true and necessary, but even these small island nations want the report,” she said.
IPS UN Bureau Report







