The Human Consciousness Now...Our World in the Midst of Becoming...to What? Observe, contemplate Now.
ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 22 2026 (IPS) - COP31 ended without an overarching climate agreement on Sunday after two days of overtime, as deep divisions over fossil fuels, climate finance and global warming prevented nearly 200 countries from reaching consensus.
The European Union, the United Kingdom, Panama and other countries rejected the proposed Antalya Pact, arguing that it failed to respond adequately to the accelerating climate crisis.
UN Secretary-General António Guterres expressed his disappointment.
“I am deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome. I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands.”
Five major disputes exposed the divisions that prevented an agreement.
“This setback does not change the facts. There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science,” he said.
In the closing plenary, Ireland’s climate minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU, said, “It’s unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuels.”
Yamide Dagnet, Senior Vice President, International, at the Natural Resources Defence Council (NRDC), said, “This year COP closes with mixed signals and a negotiated outcome that failed to meet the moment. It’s a sharp contrast to real-world clean energy progress, driven by economics, security and health concerns.”
Dagnet said it was essential to accelerating electrification with clean energy. But the most disappointing was “climate financing, especially for adaptation and resilience, which remains woefully inadequate compared to the need. When elephants fight, the grass gets trampled—and that’s what happened here, with the world’s biggest economies failing to support developing countries. This is life-or-death support for the poorest and most vulnerable people around the world who are suffering the worst impacts of the climate crisis and have contributed the least to its cause.”
Responding to the closing of the COP31 climate summit in Türkiye today, Dr Jeni Miller, Executive Director of the Global Climate and Health Alliance, a consortium of more than 300 health professionals and health civil society organisations and networks from around the world addressing climate change, said, “The COP31 process has betrayed people’s health by failing to deliver a clear plan for transitioning away from fossil fuels or providing the finance countries need to protect lives and prepare their health systems for escalating climate shocks.”
Ambassador Peter Thomson, United Nations Secretary-General’s Special Envoy for the Ocean, noted that the “great majority of countries recognise that we cannot solve the climate crisis without protecting the ocean. They now have to act on that recognition. We know that aggressively cutting fossil fuel and methane emissions are the best things we can do to safeguard the ocean’s health. There is no investment more important than in transitioning away from burning fossil fuels to an equitably electrified world powered by renewable energy.”
Steven Guilbeault, former Canadian Minister of Environment and Climate Change, said the one glimmer of hope has been the recognition of the ocean in a way we’ve never seen at UN climate talks before. We’ve desperately needed these promises of an ocean-specific roadmap, new finance, and a ramping up of blue priorities in climate plans. It’ll carry us closer to protecting 30% of the ocean by 2030. The challenge now is to build on the progress made in Antalya and turn it into real action for the ocean, for nature and for the communities that depend on them.”
Bryan Bixcul, Just Transition lead, International Indigenous Peoples Forum on Climate Change (IIPFCC), said he was “deeply troubled by the level of dysfunction we witnessed in the UNFCCC process. In the same year that science warned we are on track to exceed the 1.5°C threshold, COP31 failed to face that reality head-on and name fossil fuels as the root cause of climate change. Antalya ends without its key deal, putting the interests of petrostates and fossil fuel lobbyists ahead of people, especially Indigenous Peoples. Our territories are on the frontline of this fight.
“If drilling continues, temperatures will keep rising, our waters will be contaminated and our lands destroyed. If the energy transition moves ahead without recognising our rights and without adequate finance, a new mining push will once again kill, destroy and set us back in the fight against climate change. There is no meaningful progress on the just transition mechanism, and no clarity on climate finance. How are we supposed to trust this process?”
Fatima Eisam-Eldeen, a fossil fuel researcher with the University of Barcelona, said, “No agreement is better than a bad agreement. Where this COP failed to come to a final decision, at least it kept false solutions from being validated through the negotiations. We must not waste more precious time and resources on derailing tactics, because for frontline communities, this is a life-or-death situation. The real solution is clear: we need to phase out fossil fuels fast, in a just and orderly manner, and for that, we need mechanisms.”
Eisam-Eldeen said it would now fall on Ethiopia to clean up the mess, “raise ambition and deliver for the people who need it today. It’s a sad but well-known phenomenon: the mess made by the states with wasted interest in continuing burning fossil fuels will be cleaned up by the people suffering its consequences.”

Credit: IPS/AI-assisted graphic. Data source: UNFCCC (2026).
Fossil fuels: The transition that disappeared
Saudi Arabia and other oil-producing countries opposed stronger commitments on fossil fuels, while a coalition of more than 130 countries pushed to reaffirm the COP28 agreement to transition away from oil, gas and coal.
Although the first draft included explicit transition language, subsequent versions removed it. The final proposed text recalled the Dubai agreement without mentioning fossil fuels, prompting strong objections from the EU and vulnerable countries.
Adaptation finance: The missing US$120 billion
Developing countries, particularly in Africa, pushed for stronger financial commitments to help vulnerable communities cope with worsening climate impacts.
An earlier draft proposed increasing annual adaptation finance to at least US$120 billion by 2035. The figure was subsequently dropped, leaving only an ambition to triple funding without a clear baseline or delivery plan.
With the cover decision rejected, even this proposed commitment was not adopted.

Delegates crowd around COP31 President Murat Kurum as the climate talks stretch on beyond the deadline. Credit Kiara Worth/UN Climate Change
The 1.5°C threshold: A world heading towards overshoot
The proposed agreement acknowledged that global warming is projected to exceed the Paris Agreement’s 1.5°C threshold but offered limited new measures to address the threat.
It also promoted carbon capture technologies, proposing gigatonne-scale deployment by 2035. Critics warned that reliance on these technologies could distract from urgent emissions reductions and prolong fossil fuel dependence.
Electrification: Progress outside the failed agreement
The draft proposed increasing electricity’s share of global final energy consumption to 35% by 2035 but did not explicitly require that electricity come from renewable sources.
Although the cover decision did not adopt the target, more than 90 countries supported a separate electrification initiative.
For African countries, the challenge remains securing finance to expand electricity access, renewable energy generation and grid infrastructure.

Protestor during closing plenary. Credit: UN Climate Change/Kiara Worth
Green trade barriers: Climate action or protectionism?
Developing countries challenged unilateral climate-related trade measures, particularly the European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), warning that these could undermine export competitiveness and penalise economies lacking the resources to decarbonise.
The proposed agreement called for cooperation to prevent climate measures becoming disguised trade restrictions, but the dispute remained unresolved.
A summit without consensus
Although COP31 advanced separate initiatives and technical decisions, the failure to adopt an overarching agreement exposed deep divisions over the pace of climate action and who should pay for it.
For developing countries, particularly in Africa, the outcome leaves critical questions unanswered about adaptation finance, the transition away from fossil fuels and support for vulnerable communities.
As Guterres warned: “There may be no consensus in the negotiating room. There is no ambiguity in the science.”
IPS UN Bureau Report

UNITED NATIONS, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - Over the past two months, the humanitarian situation in Yemen has deteriorated significantly following the eruption of hostilities between Houthi forces and the Yemeni troops backed by the Saudi-led coalition on September 3. Marked by persistent attacks on key infrastructure and densely populated areas—particularly in Taiz and Lahj—civilians continue to struggle amid heightened insecurity and mass displacement, with children bearing the brunt of the crisis.
On November 18, the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) reported that at least 64 children have been killed and 64 others injured since September 3, warning that casualties are projected to soar as fighting escalates in Taiz and Lahj.
At least 7 schools and 28 health facilities, including five supported by UNICEF, have sustained damage since the wake of hostilities. On November 2, an attack on the UNICEF-supported Al-Suqyah Health Center in Lahj—which serves roughly 1,700 civilians—killed five people, including three health personnel.
Ongoing disruptions to essential services and accelerating displacement have prompted UN experts to call for an immediate end to hostilities, unimpeded humanitarian access, and compliance with international humanitarian law. During a press briefing at the UN Headquarters on November 19, Farhan Haq, Deputy Spokesperson for the Secretary-General, told reporters that conditions are “getting worse by the day.”
“The rising number of children killed and injured in Yemen is devastating. It must stop,” said UNICEF Executive Director Catherine Russell. “Behind every number is a child whose life has been cut short or changed forever…Children must be protected, including their access to essential services such as healthcare, education, safe water, and food.”
Figures from the International Organization for Migration (IOM) show that roughly 350,000 individuals have been uprooted from their homes between June 7 and November 16, with UNICEF reporting that this includes approximately 174,000 children. More than 18,000 of those civilians were forced to flee in the last week alone, according to Haq, with nearly two-thirds coming from Taiz.
Many families have been displaced multiple times, often residing in host communities whose resources are already severely strained. The majority of these families currently reside in damaged buildings that serve as makeshift shelters, where they face limited access to food, water, healthcare, and protection services.
UNICEF has expressed particular concern over the humanitarian situation in Taiz City, underscoring persistent access constraints. The main road for humanitarian aid deliveries from Aden is closed, and alternative routes remain unreliable, depriving more than 800,000 civilians of basic services.
Water production has been slashed by nearly 50 percent, while food and fuel prices have nearly doubled. Continued shortages of electricity, fuel, medicines, and oxygen jeopardize lifesaving emergency healthcare interventions, including maternal and newborn care.
Across the most severely impacted regions, UNICEF has recorded over 1,160 school closures or disruptions to learning, affecting more than 500,000 students. Since the escalation, UNICEF and its partners have found that approximately one-third of all children recently screened showed signs of acute malnutrition.
Widespread hunger—compounded by overcrowded and unsanitary displacement shelters, a shortage of latrines, and limited access to safe water- has significantly raised the risk of disease.
Earlier this month, UN Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator Tom Fletcher informed reporters that he is coordinating with Yemen’s Foreign Minister, Dr. Afrah Abdulaziz Al-Zouba, to restore humanitarian aid access. As of November 2, the UN and its partners had reached nearly 260,000 displaced civilians in Yemen with lifesaving support, though the vast scale of needs continues to outpace available resources.
“We have food and medicine ready to move,” said Fletcher. “Our asks are clear. Open the roads and let them through. Civilians cannot be held hostage by the fighting.”
In response, UNICEF has announced plans to expand its emergency response efforts to reach up to 560,000 people, positioning mobile health and nutrition teams at displacement sites and in vulnerable communities across Aden, Lahj, Taiz, Marib, and Abyan. UNICEF and its partners will also mobilize support for water and sanitation, as well as psychosocial care and case management for children, particularly those who were separated from their families.
IPS UN Bureau Report

Nov 20 2026 (IPS) -
On November 19, in Shenzhen, the leaders of China, the United States, and Russia gathered for their first-ever face-to-face trilateral summit. The meeting is historic before a single word is exchanged. Whether it becomes consequential, however, depends on what the three leaders choose to accomplish.
A New Yalta—or Something Fundamentally Different?
Comparisons of this trilateral meeting with the 1945 Yalta Conference are inevitable but potentially misleading. At Yalta, Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin represented wartime allies negotiating the final stages of a common struggle and the foundations of a postwar order. Washington sought Soviet participation in the war against Japan and support for the emerging United Nations. In return, Moscow secured promises concerning southern Sakhalin, the Kuril Islands, Outer Mongolia, and strategic privileges in northeastern China.
Shenzhen presents a fundamentally different configuration. Unlike the wartime allies at Yalta, the three participants in Shenzhen are bound together by a complex mixture of strategic competition and cooperation. Nevertheless, each has interests that could tempt observers to interpret the summit through a Yalta-style lens of spheres of influence.
Russia would welcome recognition of its territorial claims over the four Ukrainian regions it declared annexed in 2022—Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson—alongside guarantees against Ukraine’s integration into Western security structures. Washington, meanwhile, has increasingly asserted its primacy in the Western Hemisphere through what has become known as the ‘Donroe Doctrine’, seeking to limit competing powers’ strategic footholds in Latin America. Trump also hopes to enlist Moscow and Beijing in efforts to end the Iran war.
China has its own regional priorities. Beijing would prefer reduced American military pressure in East Asia, greater Russian sensitivity to Chinese interests in Central Asia, and manageable competition over influence in North Korea. The Taiwan question remains central to Beijing’s long-term political objectives, although it is unlikely to be meaningfully resolved through negotiations among the three leaders.
These interests are not necessarily compatible. Competing ambitions for spheres of influence do not imply that a grand bargain is either achievable or desirable. Unlike Yalta, Shenzhen is not expected to produce a formal agreement delineating spheres of influence or granting strategic privileges. Any private discussion of such arrangements would confront substantial political, legal, and practical obstacles, not least the objections of governments and populations whose futures would be affected.
Strategic Stability Without a Grand Bargain
The more realistic purpose of the summit is to promote strategic stability among the world’s three most consequential military powers.
Trump’s preference for personal diplomacy with leaders commanding large territories and formidable nuclear arsenals makes the gathering particularly attractive to him. For Xi and Putin, direct engagement offers opportunities to reinforce their international standing, clarify strategic intentions, and reduce uncertainty.
Even the anticipated photograph of the three leaders has diplomatic value. At a time of prolonged conflicts and intensifying geopolitical competition, visibly demonstrating a willingness to communicate can reassure international audiences that confrontation is not inevitable.
China and the United States have already embraced the concept of a “constructive relationship of strategic stability.” Shenzhen could become an opportunity to extend elements of that approach into a trilateral framework without pretending that the three bilateral relationships are equally cooperative or confrontational.
Nuclear arms control offers an especially revealing test. Since New START expired in February 2026, Washington and Moscow have lacked a functioning bilateral treaty limiting their strategic nuclear arsenals. Trump has expressed interest in a broader arrangement involving China. Yet the asymmetry remains enormous. According to SIPRI, the United States and Russia together possess approximately 86 percent of the world’s nuclear warheads, while China’s arsenal remains substantially smaller. Beijing consequently has little incentive to accept equivalent numerical constraints. Nevertheless, China’s willingness to participate in informal discussions, without accepting immediate reduction commitments, could itself constitute meaningful progress. Strategic dialogue need not begin with identical obligations.
The most substantive agreements may still emerge from bilateral rather than trilateral negotiations. In particular, the China–US relationship requires further clarification of what constructive strategic stability means in practice. Previous presidential meetings have established broad political understandings, but detailed implementation still depends heavily on negotiations among officials between summits.
Trump’s participation in the Quad summit and engagements with ASEAN leaders in Manila also provide a useful comparison. The relative time devoted to these meetings and the Shenzhen gathering, as well as their substance and diplomatic atmosphere, may reveal how his administration balances great-power accommodation with its traditional Indo-Pacific partnerships.
Turning a Historic Photograph into Lasting Stability
For Shenzhen to achieve significance beyond symbolism, several practical steps deserve consideration.
First, the three governments should establish a regular strategic-stability consultation mechanism. Initially informal and without binding obligations, it could facilitate communication on nuclear doctrine, crisis prevention, military incidents, and emerging strategic technologies. The objective should be to prevent unintended escalation rather than demand immediate agreement on fundamental disputes.
Second, nuclear negotiations should proceed on differentiated tracks. Washington and Moscow should take primary responsibility for restoring verifiable limits and transparency mechanisms, while Beijing could participate in discussions on nuclear risk reduction, early-warning communication, and confidence-building measures. This would recognize China’s comparatively smaller arsenal without excluding it from the broader conversation.
Third, conflict resolution must remain inclusive. Discussions concerning Ukraine and Iran could help identify possible areas of convergence, but no durable settlement can be negotiated over the heads of the directly affected parties. The three powers should facilitate broader diplomatic processes rather than attempt to substitute their own understandings for them.
Finally, summit diplomacy should be institutionalized rather than personalized. Working-level follow-up, agreed communication channels, and measurable confidence-building initiatives would help translate presidential understandings into practical arrangements. December’s G20 summit in Florida could provide another opportunity to assess progress, although another three-way encounter remains uncertain.
Shenzhen will not—and should not—be another Yalta. The international system is too interconnected, the principle of sovereignty too important, and other states’ interests too consequential for three leaders to redraw the global order around a negotiating table. Its more constructive historical legacy would be to demonstrate that great powers can manage strategic rivalry without demanding exclusive control over their respective neighborhoods. The success of Shenzhen should therefore be measured not by how much territory or influence the three leaders can divide, but by how much confrontation they can prevent.
Related articles:
Managing Competition: The New Logic of US–China Summitry
Beyond the Trade Truce: AI and the Next Phase of China–US Risk Management
Before Washington: Xi and the Contest Over Global Leadership
Taiyi Sun (Ph.D., Political Science, Boston University) is Associate Professor of Political Science at Christopher Newport University.
This article was issued by the Toda Peace Institute and is being republished from the original with their permission.
IPS UN Bureau

LONDON, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - India’s Gen Z cockroach movement has already forced the resignation of the education minister. Now it’s part of a mass mobilisation demanding the Hindu nationalist government reverse and be held accountable for the deletion of some 130 million names from the electoral rolls.
Last year, the Election Commission of India embarked on what it calls a Special Intensive Revision of the electoral rolls, which it says is needed to remove duplicate and ineligible names, including those of people who’ve died. With the task completed in 30 of India’s 36 states and centrally administered territories, around an eighth of the electorate has been struck off. Millions have complained that they’re eligible voters who’ve been disenfranchised.
The purge threatens to turn the universal franchise into a selective privilege, violating a fundamental principle of democracy, that every adult citizen has the same right to vote. Women are disproportionately affected, because many move states when they marry, complicating the paper trail. Muslims, long vilified by the ruling Bharatiya Janata party (BJP), are disproportionately impacted. In Bihar state, around 33 per cent of final-stage deletions were of Muslims, even though they make up roughly 17 per cent of the state’s population.
The suspicion is that the changes will benefit the BJP and Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
Deletions could swing elections. In May, the BJP won the election in West Bengal state, previously an opposition stronghold, after 9.1 million names, over 10 per cent of the electorate, were removed from the roll. In some Muslim-majority constituencies, close to half of voters were removed from the roll.
Cockroaches rise
India’s cockroach movement arose in response to an insult. In May, the country’s Chief Justice, Surya Kant, told a courtroom that unemployed young people who protested and spoke out on social media were like cockroaches. Communications strategist Abhijeet Dipke posed a simple question: what if all the cockroaches came together? The answer was a movement of millions, organised around the satirical Cockroach Janta Party.
The movement found its galvanising issue in the leak of the national medical college entrance exam paper, likely the act of corrupt officials in return for bribes. Cockroach movement protesters camped out for weeks in Delhi, until the authorities unleashed violence, beating them with batons and wooden sticks, firing teargas and arresting many. Public revulsion at the violence forced the government to hold talks with the movement, and Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan quit.
On 2 October the cockroach movement took part in nationwide protests, demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, a criminal investigation, reinstatement of deleted voters, a review of recent state elections and independent selection of election commissioners.
This time, the cockroach movement’s protests have formed part of a broader campaign. Civil society organisations have been raising the issue for some time, and established student movements, emerging leftist student leaders and opposition parties are active and vocal. The Congress party, once India’s dominant political force, has organised protests, including one attended by tens of thousands in Delhi on 1 November.
Civil society groups have also taken practical steps to help the disenfranchised, setting up helpdesks near places where excluded groups are concentrated so people can file petitions and gather the documents needed to get their vote reinstated. These efforts could make a crucial difference, as without the capacity to appeal, many risk losing their vote by default.
Stare lashes out
The government has made clear it has no intention of walking back the changes by mobilising large-scale force.
Ahead of the protest on 2 October, police barricaded Jantar Mantar, the main protest site, and set up checkpoints around the city. Police invoked section 133 of the Indian Citizen Safety Code, which bans gatherings of over four people, the use of slogans and speeches and other common protest activities, and authorities suspended internet services close to the protest site. When people protested regardless, police detained around 1,000, including student and political leaders. Police also banned a protest in Mumbai that same day.
The crackdown escalated on 10 October, when police detained several thousands, among them Dipke, detained as he arrived at Delhi airport from Mumbai, along with other leading Cockroach Janta Party figures. Authorities deployed around 30,000 officers, sealed Delhi’s borders, shut down public transport routes and stationed anti-riot vehicles with teargas launchers along major roads. Police ordered Delhi hotels to refuse customers, told Uber drivers not to drop people off near protest sites and said they were tracking food delivery services in case they were used to supply protesters. Following the protest, police ended Jantar Mantar’s designation as a protest site.
Police have twice detained Congress party leader Rahul Gandhi and put one of India’s most popular YouTubers, Dhruv Rathee, under house arrest. They’ve detained journalists covering the protests. Police have met subsequent protests with the same responses of barricades, transport restrictions, internet shutdowns and mass arrests. Still, the protests continue.
The state’s hostile response is part of a broader pattern. In recent years it has passed draconian laws that enable it to hold activists in lengthy pretrial detention, restrict civil society funding and force organisations to close, while police routinely use violence against protests. Having made it harder for people to speak out, organise and protest, now the government is taking away their right to vote.
Wider struggles
If the protest movement wins again, the repercussions will be felt beyond India. The story of India’s cockroach movement has travelled the world, inspiring others, as part of a wider wave of Gen Z-led protests that has unfolded in many countries. Young people are rising up against corruption, economies that fail them and out-of-touch politicians, and they’re having an impact. A student movement has just won power in Serbia, while high school protests in France have forced the government to concede several demands.
A Modi climbdown would offer further proof that mass organising and protesting, spearheaded by Gen Z, can make a difference. The Indian government should swallow its pride and offer dialogue instead of violence. The protesters have shown how much they value democracy, and made clear they intend to keep going until the damage the government has caused it is undone.
Andrew Firmin is CIVICUS Editor-in-Chief, co-director and writer for CIVICUS Lens and co-author of the State of Civil Society Report.
For interviews or more information, please contact research@civicus.org.

ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - Valepi Banda still remembers the day she lost dozens of chickens in June last year in Zambia’s capital, Lusaka, after the heating system failed due to power cuts.
The southern African nation was experiencing load-shedding schedules lasting eight hours a day, and the 22-year-old poultry farmer had no backup power.
Zambia, which relies on hydropower plants, was struggling after consecutive droughts caused low water levels in Lake Kariba, its largest, triggering a power crisis.
“We created a timetable for load shedding, but they never followed it. It made me sluggish,” Banda, a student at a university in Zambia, told IPS at the United Nations climate summit in Antalya, Turkey.
“I was raising some chickens in the backyard. And because broilers need heating every time, most of the chickens died.”
Banda has since stopped rearing chickens and is now keeping goats.
“I stopped chicken farming because it was too risky, and I had no buffer,” she said.
Countries like Zambia that generate about 90% of their electricity from renewables are banking on the Belém Action Mechanism (BAM), an UNFCCC framework created at COP30 in Belém, Brazil, to support workers, communities, and countries shifting toward low-carbon economies.
For Zambia and Kenya, the challenge involves not only shutting down coal-fired power plants but also expanding renewables and building electricity infrastructure to provide access to affordable electricity for poor communities.
They also want fossil-dependent countries to shift away from dirty fuels because it is their vulnerable communities who suffer from extreme weather events like floods and droughts.
Parties at COP31 in the resort of the Mediterranean country are negotiating about BAM’s operational and governance details.

Activists demand a Just Transition Mechanism at COP31 in Antalya, Turkey. Credit: Farai Shawn Matiashe/IPS
Deadlock
Developing countries want a new institution to coordinate global “just transition” efforts as nations shift away from fossil fuels as agreed at COP30 in Belém.
But developed countries are opposing this proposal, insisting that the UNFCCC coordinate the just transition.
Brandon Wu, director of policy and campaigns at ActionAid USA, said that there is no progress on the just transition.
“This is frustrating because that is what they agreed to last year. Certainly, they are worried that it will require resourcing,” he said.
“They are afraid that a powerful just transition mechanism will require some financing.”
Nona Chai of the Just Transition Alliance, a network of environmental justice groups and local unions tackling polluting extractive industries that harm communities and workers, said the European Union, United Kingdom and Japan are trying to weaken the Just Transition Mechanism and are running away from their responsibility to fund Global South countries.
“That is not acceptable because the whole reason civil society proposed the BAM in the first place is that existing resources are insufficient for a just transition,” she said.
“It is sad. It is shameful. It should not be happening. They are reversing course on all the progress that was made on the Belem-Antalya Mechanism at COP 30 last year. It was a historic win for our movements.”
Global South Demands Finance, Technical Support for Shifting From Fossil Fuels
Wu said they want a Just Transition Mechanism that provides support for developing nations.
“Whether it is technical support or capacity building. It does not all have to be just money. Money is part of it, but a lot of it is technical support and capacity building for how we design just transition plans, how we plan for changes in the economy so that we are not leaving workers behind,” he said.
Chai said that the funding must come as grants to ensure that Global South countries avoid being trapped in debt.
“We need a mechanism that will actually promote grant-based, non-debt-creating funding for Global South countries and affected groups,” she said.
Developing nations have often resorted to debt to fund renewable energy projects, adaptation and other mitigation projects. This has left many countries in debt distress.
In 2022, public debt in Africa reached USD 1.8 trillion, according to the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD).
For Banda, she wants a Just Transition Mechanism that can help her country expand renewables to complement hydro power plants exposed to droughts.
“We are looking at how best we can supplement our electricity generation because we are a country that depends on hydroelectricity. And because of the repeated effects of climate change and the drought, we have seen a decrease in the amount that we generate,” she said.
Power crisis affects small businesses, and just transition will help them access affordable clean energy, Banda said.
Africa possesses world-class solar, wind, and hydropower potential, alongside critical minerals needed for clean technologies.
It contains 60% of the world’s best solar resources, yet accounts for only about 1% of installed solar PV, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA).
But about 600 million people lack electricity access, with half of them living in three countries, namely Nigeria, Ethiopia and the Democratic Republic of Congo, according to the IEA.
Sub-Saharan Africa accounts for roughly 85% of the global population lacking electricity.
Nearly a billion people in Sub-Saharan Africa lack access to modern and clean cooking solutions.
Banda said that on a policy level, the government is trying to diversify its energy mix, but a lack of funding is a setback.
Authorities expect water levels to drop again this year in Lake Kariba, shared between Zimbabwe and Zambia, because of the anticipated El Niño.
“I am already anxious. It is triggering. I do not know how bad it will be,” she said.
IPS UN Bureau Report

DHAKA, Bangladesh, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - The world’s highest court has delivered a historic legal and moral victory. It does not get any more definitive than this. On 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) found that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State. It is the first time the court has held a state responsible for committing genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. By a 9–6 majority, the judges also found that Myanmar failed to prevent and punish genocide. The ICJ has spoken for the Rohingya. The ruling is final, and there is nowhere left to appeal. However, turning this verdict into a safe journey home will take political muscle that the court itself does not have. The international community must act now.

Dr Mohammad Zaman
The case was brought in November 2019 by The Gambia, a small West African state with no direct connection to the crimes, backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. The court examined the military’s 2017 “clearance operations” in detail: an estimated 10,000 Rohingya killed, and nearly 400 villages, about 40 per cent of those in three northern townships, partly or wholly destroyed before being bulldozed and built over. It concluded that Myanmar’s security forces intentionally killed members of the group, caused them serious bodily and mental harm, and imposed measures intended to prevent births.
Reading the judgment, ICJ President Yuji Iwasawa said: “The evidence of brutal acts of sexual violence and the targeting of children for violence in Rohingya communities also supports an inference that there was a desire to destroy the foundations of the group. The systematic nature of these actions further indicates a reasonable inference that Myanmar acted with genocidal intent.”
A legal and moral victory
The legal weight of this ruling is hard to overstate. In the 2007 Bosnia case, the court found that Serbia had failed to prevent the Srebrenica genocide but stopped short of holding it responsible for committing genocide. This time there is no such hedge. The court also made clear that genocidal intent can coexist with other aims, including military ones. That undercuts Myanmar’s long-standing claim that it was simply fighting an insurgency.
The moral victory matters just as much. For decades, the Rohingya have been denied citizenship, confined to camps and dismissed by Myanmar’s generals. Now the world’s highest court has put their suffering on the authoritative record. UN Secretary-General António Guterres called the ruling a “powerful recognition of the Rohingya victims of genocide”. That recognition cannot be undone, and it is a form of justice in its own right.
What the court ordered, and what it cannot do
The court’s directives are binding. Myanmar must stop any ongoing violations and pass legislation giving full effect to the Convention. It must investigate, prosecute and punish those responsible, and give guarantees that the atrocities will not happen again. It must also provide restitution, including the “safe, voluntary and dignified return” of displaced Rohingya to their homes and the reunification of families, and compensate the victims. Myanmar has two years to report on what it has done.
In practical terms, little is likely to change in the short run. The ICJ has no police force. Nor does it try individuals: it rules on disputes between states. The fate of Senior General Min Aung Hlaing, who oversaw the 2017 campaign and now heads the state, lies with the International Criminal Court. The ICC prosecutor’s pending warrant application against him now carries greater weight.
Enforcement and the politics of the veto
If Myanmar ignores the judgment, just as The Gambia says it failed to comply with the court’s 2020 provisional measures, The Gambia can take the matter to the UN Security Council under Article 94 of the UN Charter. This is where justice meets geopolitics. Any one of the five permanent members can veto action, and history offers little comfort. When the court ruled against the United States in the Nicaragua case in 1986, Washington vetoed the resolutions calling for compliance. In 2007, China and Russia vetoed a draft resolution on Myanmar’s human rights record.
China holds the key
No country matters more here than China. Beijing is Myanmar’s most important patron. It has shielded Naypyidaw at the UN, invested heavily in Rakhine and has acted as a broker between the junta and ethnic armed groups. Its priority is stability along its economic corridor to the Bay of Bengal, not accountability.
The situation on the ground complicates matters further. The junta has lost much of Rakhine State to the Arakan Army, and Myanmar has been in turmoil for years. When the ICJ orders a safe return to the Rohingya’s “place of residence”, Naypyidaw can simply say it no longer controls the territory. Any credible repatriation will therefore have to be negotiated with both the junta and the Arakan Army, most likely with Beijing as guarantor. China wants Rakhine stable and its investments secure. If Dhaka and its partners can show that an orderly, rights-based return serves that goal, China’s interests may line up with the court’s orders.
What Bangladesh should do now
Bangladesh has carried the heaviest burden of a crisis it did not create. About 1.4 million Rohingya now live in the camps around Cox’s Bazar. Since 2017, repatriation talks have produced little. The verdict gives Dhaka a kind of leverage it has never had before. It should use the verdict to work with allies to find out a workable solution.
First, make the judgment the baseline. Every repatriation deal should meet the court’s standard: a safe, voluntary and dignified return to the Rohingya’s original homes, not to transit camps, with a clear path to citizenship.
Second, talk to whoever controls the ground. Dhaka should engage the Arakan Army pragmatically, alongside Naypyidaw, so that any agreement can be carried out in Rakhine.
Third, work with China, not around it. Bangladesh should press Beijing to guarantee a deal and present a stable, rights-based return as good for China’s investments.
Fourth, build a coalition for compliance. Bangladesh should work with The Gambia, the OIC, the 11 states that intervened in the case, ASEAN and Japan to keep Myanmar’s compliance before the UN General Assembly and Security Council, and to hold Myanmar to its two-year reporting deadline.
Finally, keep the Rohingya at the centre. Refugees must have a voice in any negotiation. Reparations must reach those living in Bangladesh, and humanitarian funding, education and livelihoods in the camps must be protected while talks continue.
From verdict to homecoming
The ICJ has done its part. It has named the crime, identified the state responsible and set out what justice requires. The verdict will not, by itself, send a single family home. But it changes the terms of every conversation about the Rohingya from this day on. Whether it becomes a turning point or a footnote now depends on what allies and states do next, starting with Bangladesh.
Dr. Mohammad Zaman has written extensively on the Rohingya crisis since 2017. His recent edited (co-editors Robert Anderson and Kawser Ahmed) book is titled Rohingya Stories: History and Geopolitics in a Multipolar World (Springer 2025).
IPS UN Bureau

LAGOS, Nigeria, Nov 20 2026 (IPS) - In too many communities across our continent, a baby born with a cleft lip or palate is met with fear instead of a plan. Some families are told the child is cursed. Some mothers are even forced out of their homes. Yet a cleft is one of the most common and treatable conditions in medicine. A safe operation, done early, lets a child eat, speak and grow up with a bright future.
So when that child goes untreated, the problem is not biology. It is a sign that something is missing: the surgeon, the anesthetist, the nurse, the working operating room, the reliable electricity, the road to the right hospital. In this way, cleft is a bellwether for the strength of health systems overall.
Across sub-Saharan Africa, 93% of people cannot get safe, affordable surgery and anaesthesia when they need it, compared with under 4% in wealthier regions. In Ethiopia alone, roughly five million needed operations go undone each year.
From November 19 to 21, health leaders, surgeons, researchers and partners from across Africa will meet in Addis Ababa for the fourth Pan-African Surgical Healthcare Forum (PASHeF). Its goal is ambitious and overdue: a continental action framework for surgical care.

A doctor measures the nutritional development of a cleft patient at a hospital in Tanzania. Credit: Smile Train
Surgery is health care, not a luxury
For decades, surgery was treated as something that could wait until vaccines, bed nets, and clinics were in place. As a result of that longstanding underinvestment, an estimated 93 million Africans need surgical care every year, yet only about 5% receive it.
The World Health Assembly has recognized emergency and essential surgery and anaesthesia as a core part of universal health coverage. Invest in surgical capability, and you strengthen the whole hospital’s ability to deliver across a wide range of needs: emergency care, safe childbirth, trauma, cancer.
Ethiopia took that commitment seriously. In 2016, it became one of the first countries to write a national surgical plan, Saving Lives Through Safe Surgery (SaLTS).
What we have learned
Hundreds of new operating room blocks are being built at health centres, and surgical indicators are now tracked in the national health information system.
The challenges were familiar: leadership changes, too little reliable data, and no dedicated budget to reach the whole country. A study of the plan’s rollout found that government ownership was the most important ingredient for success.
Experience from outside government points the same way. Over 25 years, Smile Train’s approach has been to support local teams working inside national systems rather than fly in visiting surgeons. Those teams have now performed nearly 250,000 free cleft surgeries across Africa, more than 46,000 of them in Ethiopia since 2007. Three lessons stand out.
Build with government, not beside it. In Kumasi, Ghana, the Ministry of Health, Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital and the Ghana Cleft Foundation co-created the National Cleft Care Center. Government clinicians staff it, and cleft surgery there has gone from one day a week to every day.
Train together. When Africa’s surgical colleges agreed on a single cleft surgery curriculum, it spread across the continent in English, French and Portuguese.
Fix the basics. A well-equipped theatre is useless in a blackout, yet families are still asked to bring diesel for the generator. Solar systems installed with Kids Operating Room now power more than 85 children’s operating theatres in 28 countries, three of which are public hospitals in Ethiopia.
Together they show what works: government ownership, a local workforce, data that is tracked, and infrastructure that actually runs.
What the framework must do
The Addis Ababa forum should commit African governments to four key things:
• Put surgery in the budget. Plans without money stall. Finance ministries belong at the table from day one, and domestic funding should anchor what partners add.• Train and keep the workforce. Shared regional curricula, scholarships, and alumni networks can prepare young specialists to replace an aging generation of surgeons.
• Count what matters. Every country should track surgical access and outcomes in its national health data, as Ethiopia now does with its registry.
• Start with families. Ending the stigma around conditions like cleft takes midwives, community health workers, religious leaders and traditional rulers, not just doctors.
A year ago, the African Union and Africa CDC unveiled the Health Security and Sovereignty Agenda, a blueprint for African countries to build stronger health institutions, finance health from their own resources and grow local capacity. Surgery is where that ambition is tested: a country that can staff, equip, power and pay for its own operating theatres can meet its people’s needs on its own terms.
These steps can have a meaningful impact now and for future generations. As long as children are born, some will be born with a cleft. A poor child in a rural district deserves the same chance of a safe operation as an affluent child in a capital city. This week in Addis Ababa, Africa’s leaders can commit to making that happen.
Nkeiruka Obi is Vice President and Regional Director, Africa, Smile Train
IPS UN Bureau







