The Human Consciousness Now...Our World in the Midst of Becoming...to What? Observe, contemplate Now.
NAIROBI, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - Last week, on 11 November, Kenya discharged its last Ebola patient, just 37 days after the country recorded the first-ever case of the virus in its territory. If no new cases emerge over the next six weeks, Kenya will be officially declared Ebola free on 23 December. So far, zero community transmission has been recorded in the country.
That’s an outcome that Kenya can be proud of, and it’s not just a case of good luck. In June – shortly after the Ebola outbreak had been declared in Uganda and the Democratic Republic of the Congo, but months before Kenya saw its first case – Kenya’s National Public Health Institute (KNPHI) invited a Ugandan epidemiologist to teach some 200 Kenyan health workers the importance of investigating every health alert and looking into every unexplained death.
Using simple digital tools to both support and elevate local expertise is a quick, cost effective way to ensure that communities – and nations – stand robust in the face of outbreaks
And when Kenya’s first case was declared on October 6, KNPHI sprang into action, running twice-weekly virtual training sessions for frontline health workers and surveillance officers across the country. The Ugandan experiences, particularly on contact tracing, became essential here, helping Kenyan public health officials break the chain of transmission.
That kind of response – both nimble and far-reaching – is precisely what’s needed to contain an outbreak of a disease like Ebola. KNPHI was able to move fast and reach so many people thanks to virtual networks that were set up before the outbreak reached Kenya. Africa needs more investment in these kinds of networks, which my organization, Project ECHO, supports – not just in the middle of a crisis, but before the next emergency hits.
One reason that virtual networks are so powerful is that they elevate the voices of community members, which are our strongest shields against future outbreaks. Local health workers, officials, faith leaders, civil society groups, and trusted volunteers are often able to spot unusual health events before formal systems do.
Engaging with community leaders also allows us to combine global expertise with essential local context. As we’ve seen with Ebola, a failure to respect local traditions regarding burial practices, for example, has proven to be a serious challenge in containing the disease’s spread.
Embedding medical best practice with established and respected members of the local community – who understand the cultural context, and can work through it – can help us guard against such challenges.
Investing in virtual networks permanently strengthens local health capacity, which is ultimately our strongest protection against future outbreaks. Recent funding cuts to the WHO and other global health programs have undercut health staffing in many communities, making such networks more essential than ever.
Networks that include community health workers can also be used to spread knowledge and information to communities between outbreaks – which is just as essential as emergency response.
In Senegal, for example, the Institut Pasteur runs virtual training sessions on hemorrhagic and viral diseases that are reaching healthcare workers in communities across francophone West Africa and beyond.
And in Zambia, where the government has embraced virtual learning networks for more than a decade, regional and local information hubs are actively connecting frontline health workers with national and international expertise in real time, accelerating the sharing of evolving guidance, supporting mentorship, and creating peer networks that reduce professional isolation.
Even in conflict zones these digital networks have proved remarkably resilient. Since 2023, Sudan has been torn apart by civil war, genocide and gender-based violence. But an international digital network, built in close collaboration with local partners, has enabled global experts to train Sudanese health workers on how to treat victims of rape and other violence.
Some of the sessions have been facilitated through Telegram to accommodate the limited Internet bandwidth. Sometimes, the sessions take place late at night, when the connection is stronger.
The cases of Senegal, Zambia and Sudan show what’s possible when technology is used to serve local leadership. As we respond to the ongoing Ebola outbreak – and as we prepare for future crises – we must apply these lessons at scale.
We will always need high-level expertise and cutting-edge medicine. But we cannot let our investments in those areas distract us from investing in the networks that reach the communities on the frontlines, and that allow for cultural considerations to be taken into account. Using simple digital tools to both support and elevate local expertise is a quick, cost effective way to ensure that communities – and nations – stand robust in the face of outbreaks.
Existing virtual networks gave KNPHI the digital infrastructure it needed to move quickly in response to Kenya’s first Ebola case, broadcasting essential information to frontline health workers and surveillance officers across the country in a matter of days. Africa needs more of these virtual networks to reach communities across the continent – to protect the communities themselves, and to protect us all.
Dr. Caroline Kisia is Africa Director of Project ECHO.
ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - “This is about the survival of people, and we should not sugarcoat anything here at COP31. If you are trying to sugarcoat things, you shouldn’t be coming. We should be frustrated all the time because we are dealing with the very lives of our people.”
Tuvalu’s Minister for Climate Change and Pacific Political Champion of Mitigation, Dr Maina Vakafua Talia, does not believe there is room for complacency in the climate negotiations.
For him, the urgency is measured by whether his people will still have a country they can call home.
Talia has been part of the climate negotiations since COP18 in Doha, Qatar. Fourteen years later, he remains in the same fight, carrying a responsibility he says extends far beyond his position in government.
“I continue to be part of this because it’s important for the survival of our people,” he says.
“I think the survival element is what keeps us all going, not just for me, but for all the Pacific negotiators, our Pacific ministers, and those who have taken the fort way before us.”
At the centre of that commitment is a simple message he says the world must understand: Tuvaluans do not want to leave their islands.
“If you ask some of our elders, the answer is very straightforward. We don’t want to leave. This is our God-given land.”
For Talia, the prospect of displacement cannot be reduced to a conversation about relocation, migration or adapting to a changing environment.
It is a question of what happens to people when they lose the land that holds their history, language, culture and identity.
“Losing an island is literally losing your identity, losing your culture, losing your language, and we’re nothing. We don’t want to end up as second-class citizens in another country. We don’t want to pack and leave.”
He speaks of his mother, who has passed away, and the question he would face if he were forced to leave Tuvalu.
“My mum passed, and if I am asked to move, the biggest question for me is, ‘How are we going to look after those who are resting in the land?'”
He explains that in Pacific belief, those who have gone before are not simply gone.
“Those who went before us, they are not dead; they are just resting.”
It is this connection between land, ancestry and belonging that gives the negotiations a deeply personal meaning for him.
“The issue is not simply whether Tuvalu can adapt to rising seas. It is whether future generations will have the same relationship with their homeland that generations before them knew.”
Talia has four children and is soon to become a grandfather. He says the responsibility to keep fighting is also about the future they deserve.
“I can be in government today, and I can be outside government tomorrow, but we should never lose sight of this. We should continue to fight.”
He describes the climate crisis as an issue of justice, security and sovereignty, particularly for countries whose contribution to global emissions is negligible.
“Our contribution is almost next to nothing. It’s 0.0001. Why do our children have to suffer at the expense of other people? That’s injustice.”
It is also why he rejects the suggestion that Pacific ministers and negotiators should temper their frustration during international climate meetings.
Asked why he and other Pacific representatives appear angry during negotiations, his response is unequivocal.
“We are dealing with the very survival of our people that cannot come to COPs to speak for themselves, to tell their stories. We are here on behalf of 10,000 people. We are here on behalf of millions of people who cannot attend the COP meeting.”
For Talia, the responsibility of representing those communities demands honesty about what is happening and what is not being delivered.
“You cannot live a lie,” he said.
“You cannot romanticise climate change and tell people that you give me the money, and then we will do this. We will tick the box. No, you are playing around with the livelihoods of people.”
He says progress remains too slow, despite years of negotiations and commitments.
“We should have that feeling of being frustrated, being angry, that little changes are coming slowly, too slow.”
He is equally critical of the contradiction between financial commitments to vulnerable Pacific countries and continued investment in fossil fuels by major economies.
“We want some moral guidance, moral clarity, and moral leadership. We cannot continue to say that we will provide financial support to the Pacific, and then on the other hand, we will continue to entertain opening new coal mines or extending the life of other coal mines.”
His analogy is direct: “We cannot continue to mop the floor while not closing the tap.”
For Talia, the transition away from fossil fuels must be accompanied by political decisions that match the urgency of the climate crisis.
That is why Tuvalu is preparing to host the second international meeting on transitioning away from fossil fuels, following the process initiated in Santa Marta, Colombia, co-chaired by Colombia and the Netherlands.
He sees the meeting as an opportunity for the Pacific to take a leading role in shaping the global transition.
“Tuvalu and the Pacific never waited or stood on the sideline – we always lead and so the leadership from the Pacific is important.”
At COP31, that leadership is also reflected in the positions he is pushing through the negotiations as the Pacific’s Political Champion of Mitigation.
The region continues to fight to keep the 1.5°C temperature limit within reach, secure the continuation of the mitigation work programme and accelerate the implementation of decisions already agreed at previous COPs.
Talia says there has been strong resistance to continuing the mitigation work programme, but Pacific negotiators are working to keep it on the table.
“We want to fast-track, and we want to implement some of the decisions that have been made in previous COPs.”
He argues that keeping 1.5°C alive cannot be separated from climate finance, adaptation and implementation on the ground.
For Tuvalu, the stakes are immediate. The country has experienced dry spells in recent months, while the prospect of changing weather patterns and El Niño adds further pressure on communities already exposed to climate impacts.
“We don’t need to convince the world that they need to put money into the Pacific Resilience Facility (PRF), we don’t need to convince the world that they need to respond because it is already there,” Talia said. “They need to put money into the Loss and Damage Fund.”
His message is that the Pacific is not asking the world to imagine what climate change might mean. Its people are already living with the consequences.
After 14 years in the negotiations, Talia knows the process can be exhausting. He describes COP as psychologically damaging for those who repeatedly have to return to the negotiating rooms and argue for action on issues that determine whether their communities can remain where they are.
“We should not treat COP as a place where we meet friends or as a place where we see one another. It’s a frustrating process, and we should take advantage of the opportunity of coming and tell the world that we are not happy with how things are progressing.”
There is little separation between the political responsibility he carries and the personal future he is trying to protect.
His children, his future grandchild, the elders who want to remain on their land and the generations resting beneath it are all part of the same argument he takes into the negotiating rooms.
For Talia, the measure of success is not simply what governments agree to at the end of COP31. It is whether those decisions give Tuvaluans a genuine chance to remain on their islands, preserve their identity and determine their own future.
“We are not here to play; we are not here on a holiday trip, but we are here because of the survival of our people.”
IPS UN Bureau Report

ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - The publication timetable for several climate reports has become one of the most contentious issues at this year’s United Nations climate conference, as several fossil-fuel-dependent countries want to delay the next round of scientific assessments.
The scientific reports, released every five to seven years by the UN-backed Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), help governments plan their climate policies.
Limited Resources for Africa’s Scientists
Several African countries, including Kenya, are also among those at COP31 pushing for a delay to the report. But for them, this is not about the fact that they heavily rely on fossil fuels but about a lack of capacity building and limited resources. Kenya generates 90% of its electricity from renewables, according to the International Energy Agency.
Patricia Achieng’ Nying’uro, Kenya’s (IPCC) Focal Point, said that Kenya’s position on the Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) timeline comes down to capacity, not politics.
“We are in favour of a schedule that gives our technical reviewers, negotiators, and authors enough time and support to engage properly with the process,” she told reporters at the Conference of the Parties, or COP31, in Antakya, Turkey.
“We have a history of under-representation across the cycles, and we have an opportunity with AR7 to remedy this to some extent.”
The IPCC Seventh Assessment Report (AR7) cycle began in July 2023. Member governments have not agreed on a final delivery date.
Countries like China, Saudi Arabia, India and Russia are pushing to delay the report from 2028 to 2029, saying they want wider participation from developing nations.
Countries like Chad and some island nations want to align AR7 publication timelines and budget lines with the 2028 Global Stocktake.https://www.ipcc.ch/meeting-doc/ipcc-65/
At the IPCC’s 65th plenary session in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in October, Chair Jim Skea suspended the session after delegates did not agree on the dates.
Nying’uro said several of the authors already involved in AR7 have raised concerns about time and workload constraints.
“As an example, many scientists from developing countries, including the focal point teams, are not given dedicated time off their regular jobs for IPCC work, so they are juggling it alongside everything else they do,” she said.
Nying’uro said a compressed timeline only deepens that strain and risks the region being under-represented in the final product.
“Ultimately, what we care about most is that the IPCC’s assessment stays robust and genuinely representative of the regions it covers, and we think that depends as much on giving people the capacity to do the work well as it does on the calendar itself,” she said.
Countries Making Profit From Fossil Fuels Protect Own Interests
Critics say that China, Russia, Saudi Arabia and India, countries that make billions of dollars from fossil fuels, are protecting their own interests under the guise of inclusivity of developing nations.
Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland and founding member of The Elders, an independent group of global leaders, said that developed nations can address the lack of resources and capacity building for scientists from developing countries without delaying the report.
“There are legitimate concerns among African countries about capacity building, and they should be addressed. But that is a separate, important issue on its own. It is not a reason to hold up, try to undermine the IPCC itself,” she said.
She said it is important for the Seventh Assessment Report to be published in time for the next Global Stocktake.
“We know that science is under attack in different parts of the world, and there is a lot of disinformation and misinformation. Actually, those timelines are the timelines that the scientists have agreed on. And they should proceed,” Tubiana said.
She said that countries like Saudi Arabia are blocking the release of the report, but vulnerable countries like Nepal and island nations want its release so they can make informed decisions.
“Because it is vital for them to prepare themselves. And also, the least developed countries and developing countries can benefit much from the assessment reports,” Tubiana said.
“The most vulnerable of the developing countries badly want this report because they do not have the capacity to have separate reports. They rely on the report.”
The AR7 will provide coverage for loss and damage for the first time.
Laurence Tubiana, chief executive officer of the European Climate Foundation, said that the delay is not about scientific position but political.
“Equity is important. The contribution of scientists from the Global South, wherever they are, is very central. The real motive behind this attack is that it is a political enterprise. It is not scientific positioning,” she said.
Tubiana said that there is a need to mobilise resources to capacitate the least developed and developing countries.
“This is true and necessary, but even these small island nations want the report,” she said.
IPS UN Bureau Report

MONTREAL, Canada, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - The United States isn’t just lagging behind the global effort to protect biodiversity, it’s pulling in the opposite direction. When the 196 nations that are parties to the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity concluded their annual 17th Conference of Parties (COP17) in Yerivan, Armenia, last month, the only member state not there (also the only one that hasn’t ratified the CBD) was the United States. It’s an outlier on both biodiversity and the gender issues related to it.
Russia, China, even North Korea are parties to the CBD and sent delegations to COP17. During negotiations Russia objected to language about “human rights-based approaches and inclusive participation,” but in the end all parties, Russia included, agreed to call for “full, equitable, inclusive, effective, and gender-responsive approaches and participation as well as rights,” to consider women’s roles, knowledge, and practices regarding wildlife management, “and apply gender-responsive approaches, in line with the Gender Plan of Action.” The United States alone stands apart from that Plan, in which the CBD formally recognizes gender equity and reproductive agency matter for biodiversity and sustainability.
They matter because converting wild habitat to human needs, especially crops and livestock grazing, drives land degradation and biodiversity loss, and tracks closely with population trends. Greater gender equity correlates with fewer unintended pregnancies, slower population growth, stronger environmental policies, and lasting environmental, social, and economic benefits.
Women and girls are on the front lines. They’re disproportionately affected by land degradation and deforestation, droughts, and floods; they’re more likely to be displaced or die from climate events. They’re usually the ones securing food, water, and firewood for their families, producing up to 80% of food in rural areas, and managing crop and grazing lands. It therefore stands to reason that they should be considered and consulted on protecting land, water, biodiversity, and the climate.
The U.S. didn’t just fail to support this principle. It went out of its way to oppose it.
At a related summit meeting in Mongolia in September on the UN Convention to Combat Desertification (CCD), the U.S. delegation alone objected to gender-responsive approaches (for example to drought response) and to including civil society and “synergies” (i.e., coordinating implementation of the CCD with other Rio conventions on biological diversity and climate change). That effectively tabled those issues until the next CCD summit.
Yet gender-responsiveness, inclusivity, and a synergistic approach to the nexus between population trends and sustainability are indispensable for protecting biodiversity and the planet. Until recently this would have been an uncontroversial statement, but now the U.S. has ceded leadership on these fronts and is working to roll them back, protecting biodiversity is up to the rest of the world, and it’s not on track.
The CBD aims to preserve at least 30% of the world’s land, inland waters, and coastal and marine biodiversity by 2030 (“30×30” for short) and mobilize at least $200 billion a year to reverse biodiversity losses. But the CBD’s own review found most national biodiversity targets aren’t within reach, nor is the 30×30 goal. COP17 laid out the “Yerivan Pathway” to accelerate action, but financing is short by $700 billion a year.
To meet CBD goals, we’ll need to focus and invest more, not less, in gender equity and the nexus between population trends, climate change, and biodiversity. We’ll need to insist on implementing the Gender Plan of Action, recognize under-resourced women’s organizations not only as stakeholders but as decisionmakers and implementers, and fund them accordingly. We’ll also need to recognize that since upholding reproductive rights is central to gender equity, it’s also central to sustainable development, as The Guttmacher-Lancet Commission has shown.
Family planning, reproductive health, and gender equity are central to protecting the climate and biodiversity as well as advancing human welfare. Enabling people to choose whether and when to have children reduces unintended pregnancies, improves women’s health, slows population growth, and eases pressure on ecosystems.
Better reproductive health also leads to greater agency, education, economic empowerment, and workforce participation for women. This pays gigantic dividends. If we spent $79 billion on meeting unmet family planning and maternal health needs by 2030, it would yield $660 billion in economic benefits. That could help position countries to fund more biodiversity protection.
Gender equity and reproductive rights are essential to biodiversity, not incidental. It’s not enough to fund protected areas or restoration projects; any lasting conservation also needs robust family planning, maternal and community health, so pressure on nature eases and women can make their contributions to stewardship. It’s part of the transformative change nature needs.
This would be easier to achieve if the United States were funding instead of fighting it. The world can have effective biodiversity action without an American buy-in, but we won’t get it without focusing on the needs, rights, and empowerment of women.
Céline Delacroix is adjunct professor at the University of Ottawa’s School of Health Sciences, a senior fellow with the Population Institute, and director of the FP/Earth Project.
This story was originally published by the The Revelator
IPS UN Bureau

Excerpt:
The recent United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity called for gender-responsive approaches. The United States objected and is the only nation not accepting the plan.ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 19 2026 (IPS) - In the five years since the UN’s COP26 climate talks called for adaptation finance to double, some 3,610 lives have been lost and another 6.5 million people affected by floods, hurricanes, droughts, and wildfires across the Caribbean.

Daniel M. Best
Not only is the region disproportionately impacted by climate hazards, but the intensity of climate extremes is growing, resulting in a widening climate finance gap.
The latest warning from the Caribbean Institute for Meteorology and Hydrology (CIMH) is unequivocal: persistent heat, reduced rainfall, drought, and growing pressure on water resources are becoming more pronounced. Unlike hurricanes, drought and extreme heat do not announce themselves with a single moment of landfall. They intensify gradually, placing sustained pressure on communities, economies, and public services. Climate risk, therefore, is not simply an environmental concern; it is a fundamental development challenge.
Multilateral Development Banks have an important role to play in securing resilient futures, but we must work together to reduce fragmented support while at the same time, pursue financial innovation. To this end, the Caribbean Development Bank (CDB) is developing a regional country platform with the Green Climate Fund and a multi-guarantor debt-swap facility with the World Bank, Inter American Development Bank (IDB), and Central American Fund for Development in Latin America and the Caribbean.
It is also expanding lending capacity through an Exposure Exchange Agreement with the Central American Bank for Economic Integration (CABEI0, a Government of Canada credit guarantee of US$400 million, and a pioneering Contingent Capital Facility to create Tier 2 capital that can support additional lending.
But MDBs cannot deliver climate-resilient futures alone. As I watch COP31 unfold, there are three priorities I would like to see advanced.
First, discussions at this year’s UN COP31 climate talks must move from promises to delivery on adaptation finance.
It is estimated that adaptation funding would have to increase six-fold to meet the needs of Caribbean nations and other Small Island Developing States (SIDs). Last year’s commitment to triple adaptation finance was welcome, but the true measure of success will be whether countries can access the resources needed to build resilience on the ground.
This is particularly important as countries seek to translate climate strategies and commitments into investable projects that support climate-resilient cities, strengthen food security, protect oceans and coastal ecosystems, and build health systems capable of withstanding climate shocks.
Second, negotiators should lobby for the global climate finance architecture to evolve to become more accessible, affordable and responsive to vulnerability.
Roughly half of the Bank’s borrowing members have debt-to-GDP ratios above 60 per cent, placing them at risk of debt distress. The CDB’s US$460 million Special Development Fund programme, our largest concessional lending and grant programme, along with our accreditation to institutions that provide grant and soft loans, support the region but more needs to be made available. Equally important is how eligibility for these concessional resources is determined. Criteria that more explicitly incorporate vulnerability should be adopted as it is more closely aligned, both practically and conceptually, with the real risks facing small states.
Countries need financing arrangements in place before disasters occur. Insurance, contingent credit, and debt-payment pause clauses can play complementary roles. Insurance can transfer specified risks; credit can provide liquidity; and a payment pause can create breathing space. These benefits must be weighed against costs and future repayment obligations.
Lastly, negotiations should focus on keeping the goal of limiting warming to 1.5°C within reach to avoid even worse climate extremes. Every fraction of a degree matters and carries profound implications for our communities, our economies and, in some cases, our very existence.
Achieving that goal will require a faster transition to clean energy, tangible action to reduce methane and other greenhouse gas emissions, and sustained investment in sustainable production and consumption. The world must close the gap between ambition and action.
The test before us is no longer whether we understand the risks. We do. The question is whether we will match the urgency of the challenge with the ambition of our response.
For vulnerable nations, delay carries a cost measured not in dollars, but in lives, livelihoods and lost development gains. The choices made at COP31 will reverberate far beyond the negotiating halls, shaping the resilience and prosperity of communities for decades to come.
Daniel M. Best is President of the Caribbean Development Bank
IPS UN Bureau

ANTALYA, Türkiye, Nov 18 2026 (IPS) - You cannot build a wind turbine, electric vehicle, battery or solar grid without critical minerals. Lithium, nickel, cobalt, graphite and rare earths are as essential to the clean-energy transition as renewable power itself.
Yet at COP31 in Antalya, where governments are negotiating how to deliver a “just transition” away from fossil fuels, critical minerals remain largely absent from the political spotlight. While negotiators debate fairness, jobs and decarbonisation, countries elsewhere are forging mineral alliances, securing supply chains and pursuing strategic resource deals outside the UN climate process.
The disconnect raises a central question: Can the global energy transition be called just if it fails to address where the minerals will come from, who controls them, and who bears the environmental and social costs of extracting them?
That question sits at the heart of an emerging debate at COP31. The transition to clean energy depends on a vast expansion of mineral extraction, yet the governance systems needed to ensure fairness, accountability and community participation remain fragmented and incomplete.

Joan Carling, leader of Indigenous Peoples Rights International (IPRI), warns that the current push for just transition will fail if critical minerals and indigenous peoples are not made central to the issue. Credit: Stella Paul/IPS
Whose Minerals, Whose Future?
For Indigenous peoples, the debate is not theoretical.
Joan Carling, a 2024 Right Livelihood Award laureate and executive director of Indigenous Peoples Rights International (IPRI), said the transition to a low-carbon economy must not come at the expense of Indigenous communities.
According to Carling, Indigenous territories hold an estimated 54 percent of critical mineral deposits. That makes Indigenous communities central to the energy transition, whether they are included in decisions or not.
Carling acknowledges an important breakthrough achieved at COP30 in Belém, where negotiators recognised Indigenous peoples’ rights to land, territories, resources, self-determination and free, prior and informed consent. It was a milestone, she says, but recognition alone is not enough.
“It’s our resources; it’s going to be our minerals, and our lands will be used for the transition. We’re not at the table. We’re not the ones taking the decisions,” Carling said.
Her concern extends beyond representation. As demand for transition minerals rises, she fears the world could simply replace one extractive model with another.
“Just moving away from fossil-fuel extractivism to extractivism again for critical minerals,” she said.
The consequences, she argues, are already visible in many Indigenous territories.
“We’ve already seen the legacy of mining, which has completely devastated our territories, destroyed our livelihoods and our food systems, and polluted rivers and water bodies,” she said.
For Carling, the issue is not merely whether mining should occur, but who gets to define the terms under which it takes place. Indigenous peoples, she argues, continue to be treated primarily as stakeholders to consult rather than as rights-holders with decision-making authority.
As global demand for critical minerals accelerates, many Indigenous leaders fear that climate goals could become the latest justification for projects imposed on communities without meaningful participation. In that scenario, the transition may reduce carbon emissions while reproducing long-standing patterns of exclusion and extractivism.

Participants discuss mechanisms of just transition at the Just Transition pavilion at COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye. Credit: Stella Paul/IPS
A Fight Over the Meaning of ‘Just’
Inside the COP31 negotiations, advocates are working to ensure that the transition is not discussed solely in technical or economic terms.
While critical minerals are largely absent from the draft political declaration, they have not disappeared entirely from the discussions.
Negotiators at COP31 are currently working to establish a Just Transition Mechanism intended to help countries translate broad commitments into practical action.
The mechanism is expected to be one of the principal outcomes of the COP31 talks, making debates over rights, participation and value addition especially important for mineral-producing communities.
Annabella Rosemberg, senior adviser on just transition at Climate Action Network (CAN), says the evolving Just Transition Mechanism includes references to mineral extraction, Indigenous rights, local participation and value addition.
For Rosemberg, however, the larger challenge is ensuring that social justice receives the same attention as technological deployment.
“There is much more talk about electrification than there is about just transition,” she said. “What needs to be rebalanced is not only talking about targets; it’s also talking about how we centre communities.”
She argues that climate negotiations can still play an important role by legitimising alternative development models that place local communities, Indigenous rights and equitable economic benefits at the center of the transition.
“This decision on minerals is at least giving legitimacy to a different story that needs to be told,” Rosemberg said. “Where rights are important, where community voices are important, and where value addition is important.”
Still, she warns that progress on language does not automatically translate into action.
“We’re getting great language on just transition,” she said. “But we need to have something that has some teeth to make it happen.”
That challenge runs through many of the discussions at COP31. Negotiators increasingly agree on broad principles, but implementation remains uncertain. Without stronger institutions, clearer accountability mechanisms and dedicated financial support, advocates fear that commitments to justice could remain largely aspirational.
The risk, Rosemberg says, is that communities see endless consultations, reports and policy statements while decisions continue to be made elsewhere.

Japan’s Minister of the Environment Hiroyoshi Sasagawa speaks on innovation and knowledge exchange for implementing climate decisions at COP31, while the prime minister of the country attended the QUAD summit, where critical minerals emerged as a leading subject. Credit: Stella Paul/IPS
Producer Countries Seek a Bigger Share
The debate extends beyond Indigenous communities to countries expected to supply the minerals needed for the energy transition.
Brazil, for example, possesses significant reserves of graphite, nickel, lithium, niobium and rare earths. In September 2026, the country adopted a National Policy on Critical and Strategic Minerals and established a dedicated council within the Presidency, signalling a growing recognition of the sector’s strategic importance.
“There is no energy transition without mining,” said Gabriella Salazar, a Brazilian mining law specialist.
As demand for minerals grows, countries like Brazil face a familiar dilemma. They possess the resources required by industrialised economies but risk remaining suppliers of raw materials while higher-value manufacturing and processing activities occur elsewhere.
Salazar argues that producer countries should have opportunities to capture more of the economic value generated by the transition.
“My suggestion would be for the COP31 just transition outcomes to formally recognise critical minerals as an integral part of the energy transition supply chain,” she said.
Such recognition, she argues, could help unlock investment, technical cooperation and capacity-building that would allow producing countries to move beyond extraction and into refining, processing and manufacturing.
The question of value addition has become a recurring theme among developing countries. Many governments see the clean-energy transition not only as an environmental necessity but also as a potential development opportunity. Whether that opportunity materialises may depend on how future supply chains are structured and who captures the greatest economic benefits.
COP Talks, ASEAN Acts
The debate has now spread beyond COP31 negotiations.
While negotiators in Antalya debate the principles of a just transition, governments elsewhere are moving to secure access to the minerals needed to power it.
On November 17, leaders gathered for the 46th ASEAN Summit in Manila, where critical minerals were among the issues expected to be discussed, according to Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese. Yet unlike artificial intelligence and regional economic cooperation, critical minerals did not emerge as a prominent feature of the summit’s official outcome statement.
That absence reflects a broader trend. Rather than being addressed through a dedicated multilateral framework, questions of mineral security, processing capacity and supply-chain resilience are increasingly being pursued through regional discussions, bilateral agreements and strategic partnerships.
An IISD analysis of more than 200 recent trade and economic agreements found that 139 contained critical-mineral provisions, highlighting how mineral diplomacy is largely advancing outside the UN climate process.
Among them is the France-Malaysia agreement on critical minerals cooperation, signed ahead of COP31, which aims to strengthen collaboration on mineral supply chains, processing and investment. Critical minerals have also featured prominently in discussions among the Quad countries, reflecting mounting concern over access to the resources needed for the energy transition.
The contrast with COP31 is striking. While negotiators in Antalya focus on emissions reductions, climate finance and the principles of a just transition, many of the practical decisions shaping future mineral supply chains are increasingly being made elsewhere.
The result is a widening governance gap. Climate negotiators are debating what a just transition should look like, while the architecture of the critical-minerals economy is taking shape beyond the COP process.
The Missing Global Rulebook
That fragmentation worries Michael Franczak, an economic governance researcher at the United Nations University Centre for Policy Research (UNU-CPR) and co-author of the recent report, Governing Critical Minerals: Advancing Global Cooperation in a Fragmented Landscape.
“Critical minerals may be absent from the official COP31 agenda, but they are hovering over everything,” Franczak said.
According to Franczak, no single institution currently governs the intersection of mining, energy, trade, investment, industrial strategy and development. Yet all of these sectors increasingly influence the success or failure of the global energy transition.
The absence of an overarching framework leaves countries, communities and companies navigating a rapidly evolving landscape shaped by overlapping institutions and competing priorities.
Rather than calling for a single new treaty, Franczak advocates a more pragmatic approach that is based on stronger coordination among existing organisations. Such a system could improve transparency, strengthen standards, expand participation by producing countries and create mechanisms for addressing cross-border challenges that no single institution can manage alone.
The goal, he argues, is not to slow the energy transition but to ensure that it unfolds in a fair, predictable and accountable manner.
Without that coordination, the world risks repeating mistakes that have long characterised global resource extraction, where wealth accumulates far from the places where resources are extracted.
A Race Against Time
As COP31 enters its final days, the question facing negotiators is no longer whether critical minerals matter to the energy transition.
The question is whether global governance can catch up with a rapidly accelerating mineral race before inequalities become embedded in the foundations of the green economy.
For Indigenous communities, the challenge is ensuring that rights are respected and consent is meaningful. For producer countries, it is securing a fair share of the economic opportunities created by the transition. For policymakers, it is designing institutions capable of connecting climate goals with trade, development and resource governance.
The energy transition may be essential for addressing climate change, but experts warn that its legitimacy will ultimately depend on how its benefits and burdens are distributed.
As governments rush to build the clean-energy economy, Franczak cautions against assuming that cleaner technologies automatically produce fairer outcomes.
“Without better rules and stronger cooperation, we risk repeating an old pattern: resources are extracted in developing countries, while much of the economic value is captured elsewhere and local communities bear the environmental and social costs,” he warns
IPS UN Bureau Report

Nov 18 2026 (IPS) -
CIVICUS discusses protests sparked by the mass removal of voters from India’s electoral rolls with Sanjana, a young development professional based in New Delhi who has joined the protests and volunteered at a voter helpdesk.

Sanjana
What’s wrong with the electoral roll revision?
For a start, it has no precedent. The Manual on Electoral Rolls of the Election Commission of India (ECI), published in March 2023, lists four types of revision, and the current ‘Special Intensive Revision’ (SIR) is not one of them. Yet the ECI presents it as routine, claiming it has been conducted eight times since independence.
The core problem is that the SIR is flipping the burden of proof. It used to be the state’s job to enrol every eligible adult. Now people have to prove they belong. The most controversial requirement is that voters prove they, their parents or grandparents appeared on the 2002 rolls. Software then checks these links for ‘logical discrepancies’, such as a parent who appears to have too many children.
The system flagged 13.1 million voters in West Bengal state and 23.5 million in Madhya Pradesh, 17 and 41 per cent of voters in those states. Within weeks, the Bengal figure fell to around 9.5 million because the ECI changed the criteria for what counted as a discrepancy partway through. In Goa, 97 voters were left off the final roll because of software issues, even after officials cleared them. In Uttar Pradesh, the software auto-generated 87,127 forms to delete voters without giving any reason.
There’s dissent even inside the ECI. Two commissioners recorded objections to decisions taken without their knowledge 14 times in 10 months. The ECI has also centralised control over the software, to the point that states have written to the central government to complain they have no access.
Who’s being excluded?
As many as 130 million names have been struck off the rolls across 30 states and territories, with Delhi the hardest hit. Almost 33 per cent of its voters were excluded at the draft stage.
In Bihar, the first state to go through the SIR, the exercise crashed the state’s elector-to-adult population ratio from 97 to 88 per cent, against 99 per cent nationwide. In Bengal, over nine million voters were deleted. In Karnataka, the figure was nearly 10 million, with Bengaluru alone losing over 4.3 million. Overall, at least 120 million eligible adults are likely to be left off the final SIR lists.
The appeals system barely works. In Bengal, of 2.22 million appeals seeking reinstatement, only 1,607 voters were restored in time to vote in the 2026 state election. Can the result be considered valid? Some ask whether those voters would have backed the Trinamool Congress, the main rival to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s party in the state. But the real problem is that they could not vote at all, whoever they would have chosen. In a democracy, every citizen’s vote should count.
Those struck off are the people least likely to have the right documents. First of all, women are affected. An analysis in The Hindu found that in the nine Bihar constituencies with the most deletions, 56 per cent of those deleted were women, mostly aged 18 to 39. This points to married women, since marriage is the main reason women move. A woman who moved to her husband’s village is now asked to trace herself back to a 2002 roll. The gender gap on the rolls had narrowed from two million to 700,000 women by early 2025. The SIR pushed it back up to 1.6 million.
Analysis of the Bihar SIR also shows that Muslims made up 24.7 per cent of the 6.5 million voters excluded from the draft rolls and 33 per cent of those deleted from the final list, despite comprising only 16.9 per cent of the state’s population. This matches what I saw at the helpdesk where I volunteered in Nizamuddin, a mostly Muslim neighbourhood of Delhi.
Migrant workers, urban poor people and displaced people have also been disproportionately affected. When your home is bulldozed, your address disappears with it. The problem is so widespread that Delhi’s election office had to hold special camps for people whose neighbourhoods had been demolished. The state demolishes your home and then asks you to prove where you live.
The ECI keeps saying a notice is not a deletion. But for a domestic worker who has to miss a day’s wages, find a lawyer and chase a landlord for a rental agreement, the notice is the punishment. The government is disenfranchising people without saying so.
How are civil society groups helping people get back on the rolls?
Civil society groups such as Voter Adhikar Manch have set up helpdesks close to where excluded groups live, with volunteers who help people file petitions and gather the documents they need to answer their notices.
Many people have been flagged for ‘logical discrepancies’ by software that had not been properly tested. In Nizamuddin, for instance, many cases carried the same flag: ‘You have been linked as son/daughter with someone who is claimed by six others as father, giving suspicion of a likely incorrect match’. That’s absurd in a country with a long history of large families. Many people who had moved house were put on the list of ‘absent, shifted or dead’ voters.
In Nizamuddin, there was a case of a domestic worker who’d received a notice in English, which she didn’t understand. She missed a day’s work to come to us. It turned out she had no document to prove her current address. Her old voter ID card listed Sunder Nagar, a settlement the government demolished in 2023. She’s lived in the same rented home in Nizamuddin since December 2023, but the landlord refuses to give her a rental agreement. The lawyer at the helpdesk offered to speak to the landlord, but she feared retaliation and losing her home. So the lawyer wrote a letter to the ECI asking for police verification of her residence instead.
So much effort, money and distress just to vote in a democracy. Of course this exercise will disenfranchise the poor. It’s an old authoritarian tactic. Helpdesks support people nearby, but India is vast and they cannot reach every neighbourhood. What happens to everyone else?
Who’s leading the protests and what are they demanding?
The protest movement against the SIR is a broad coalition. Alongside opposition leaders, leftist parties and left-wing student organisations such as the All India Students’ Association (AISA) and the Students’ Federation of India, it includes the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP).
CJP has mass appeal among Gen Z and draws a liberal crowd. Its pull was clear in the July protests calling for the education minister to resign over leaked papers in the national medical entrance exam. Because the protests focused on a single issue, the crowd swelled across ideological and party lines. After that success, CJP launched campaigns such as ‘Fix the Schools’, which flags failings in schools across rural India. Through these campaigns and an active social media presence, it has kept a spirit of dissent alive among large numbers of liberal young people.
The protest coalition wants Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar to resign and the SIR rolled back with its deletions declared void. But some groups go further. CJP wants an inquiry and criminal charges against Kumar, a freeze on the 2025 electoral rolls and elections held on those rolls. It also wants an independent body to select election commissioners. AISA wants wrongly deleted voters restored and the 2023 law on appointing election commissioners repealed, since it removed the Chief Justice from the selection panel and gave commissioners sweeping legal immunity. The Congress party and others such as the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam have also demanded a return to ballot papers.
Everyday people have taken to the streets, asking why the government is protecting Kumar when the ECI is supposed to be autonomous and the public is calling for his impeachment.
How have authorities responded?
The October protests at Jantar Mantar, Delhi’s designated protest site, were met with aggressive repression. Instead of holding Kumar to account, the government deployed 40,000 security personnel in Delhi to confront the people protesting against him, some of them pulled from sensitive security zones. Ahead of the protest, it shut 57 metro stations and cancelled trains to Delhi. It had CJP leaders arrested and several of their allies put under preventive detention or house arrest and made to sign ‘peace bonds’ barring them from future protests.
The state’s strategy of exhaustion also targets leaders beyond CJP. Neha Bora, a young AISA activist, has endured repeated illegal detentions and refuses to sign a peace bond. At a hearing on her case, a mob of 50 to 60 Hindu nationalist supporters chanted slogans such as ‘beat the traitors of the country with shoes’ and made direct threats, right outside a police station. Police have even picked up bystanders in the name of ‘keeping peace’.
How does the struggle for voting rights connect with other struggles?
Beyond Delhi, political momentum is building on many issues. Protests against caste discrimination in universities, against Google data centres and against land grabs share a common message: the people of India have had enough of the Modi regime.
These protests also face harsh repression. In Assam, Indigenous rights activist Pranab Doley, who has led protests against a proposed luxury hotel near Kaziranga National Park, was detained under the National Security Act, a preventive detention law, a day after he was granted bail. The project threatens people’s livelihoods and relationship with the area’s rich biodiversity. In Arunachal Pradesh, authorities have met protests against the Siang Upper Multipurpose Project, a planned mega-dam, with brutal repression. Police used teargas and authorities charged four activists under the state’s anti-terror law.
The movement needs to treat every protest as part of a broader anti-authoritarian wave. Anger over voting rights is intense, and the crowds it has brought onto the streets have opened space to speak out on many issues, including Palestine. But in this charged atmosphere, the movement must not lose sight of high unemployment, inflation, levels of income inequality that are worse than under British rule, women’s safety, land grabs, and caste-based atrocities and discrimination, which hit the most excluded people hardest. The movement in Delhi must connect with these struggles across the country.
What’s needed to protect voting rights?
The SIR must be halted completely and its irregularities examined by the judiciary. Kumar must resign, and the 2023 law that shields the ECI from action must be repealed. Then the Supreme Court must hear the case against those responsible, based on an audit by independent bodies that include civil society. Above all, the state must go back to registering every eligible voter instead of making people prove they have the right to vote.
Even if fewer people had been deleted, there would still be good reason to protest. What we object to is the intention behind the exercise, whatever the numbers. We defend the right of every citizen to vote.

CIVICUS interviews a wide range of civil society activists, experts and leaders to gather diverse perspectives on civil society action and current issues for publication on its CIVICUS Lens platform. The views expressed in interviews are the interviewees’ and do not necessarily reflect those of CIVICUS. Publication does not imply endorsement of interviewees or the organisations they represent.
India is currently on the CIVICUS Monitor watchlist, which identifies countries where a severe deterioration in the quality of civic space is taking place.
SEE ALSO
Gen Z protests: new resistance rises CIVICUS | State of Civil Society Report 2026
India’s revolt against disenfranchisement CIVICUS Lens 06.Nov.2026
India’s young people find their voice CIVICUS Lens 07.Aug.2026






